Return of Newbie Maf 5

[sketchwick]

Sorry to mess up the last night, OG, I'm an impatient little man. You did a great job as mod, IMO.

sketchwick

[OcularGold]

If anyone is curious, and wants to analyze the game more, the night activities by round of the cops/docs were:

Corsato (cop): dragon phoenix, saberkitty

HorseriderMS (cop): neo, dragon phoenix, mathgrant, mikegoo

mathgrant (doc): (unknown), cubestudent,

ralpherridew (doc): dragon phoenix, zealot, zealot, zealot

(I don't know who soothsayer or mathgrant protected first round).

---

If you guys didn't know, I needed the cops first night search target and result to determine if they were sane/insane, etc.

and great game analysis, zealot. i'm very impressed.

I had a lot of trouble deciding over the rule changes proposed the last two rounds. I felt it necessary to not institute any changes to keep it fair to the Corleones, although it would almost guaruntee their win. Then again, they earned their advantage.

I hope i didn't rush you guys with the deadlines, but I felt that some of the rounds were moving too slowly at points - and theres very few things less interesting than a still mafia game, which is also the reason why I took control of the game quickly. I was afraid that people would lose their interest and begin to not come back (A fire inside never did). I never received a reply from puzzleprodigy..

any other questions or comments? i appreciate any feedback on my modding style.

[OcularGold]

[sketchwick]

Who did the Capones try to kill night one?

OG, my friend berated me for "posting at night." I had to explain that they way you mod (which I prefer) the day is over if majority is reached or deadline, none of this voting after deadline crap. Since this day ending meant end of the game I decided I didn't care if the last capone killed me, I only cared that Corleones won.

And I agree with OG, zealot does great game analysis. And OG, again, great job...you on the maiting list to mod on mafiascum?

sketchwick

[SaberKitty]

wow- i get back from my band concert, go to sleep and wake up 10 min ago. spiffy- go Sketch!!! go Zealot too for that matter!!! my bus comes in 10 min, gotta go- but neo, as i said on aim, i wasn't going to be here- had i been here i would have probably screwed things up. ,but, yay us!
-SK

[mikegoo]

Thanks for running things OG. I would just like to say that doing everything possible to look like the worlds worst mafioso...switching my vote to someone I claimed I thought was innocent day 1...throwing the last vote on 2 bandwagons when the lynching is already guaranteed...being the first person to post their suspiscions on a day in the late game and putting them in with crap logic...it doesn't work very well. It seems people would rather believe you are an incredibly inept mafia member than a townie doing things that aren't really all htat bad for a townie to do. When nobody notices it doesn't help either. I'll chalk this up to me being not so good at this game (although I did have zealot and SK figured out, I'm just not so good at getting people to follow me) and my not paying very close attention for a few game days after the mod switch...I was paying attention near the end of my days though. I'm still wondering why noone noticed that after voting for SK, I got killed. If SK were town, neither mafia team would have gone after me...I would have just been some stupid townie barking up the wrong tree.

Good game mafia folks...both teams.

[Orbiting]

Good job mafia folks - I really thought SK was innocent at the end, even though I had thought her to be a bad guy early on... oh well.
-o-

[makemeok]

Zealot: actually, i don't think there was much thought put into killing Damelon. Mentat suggested him, and i said okay. i dunno about Mentat, but i didn't think he was the cop.

sketchwick: we had some e-mail trouble the first night, so we didn't really get to discuss it. planet_buzz and i had decided on ralphmerridew, but Mentat didn't know and had to pick someone before the deadline. he picked DP. (i think that's all right... correct me if i'm wrong, Capones).

and yeah, thanks again for taking over, OG.

and thanks to everybody who actually played.

[Zealot]

Well, it sounded like a good theory . It even would have worked had I been smart enough to actually look at Damelon's post

[Mentat]

Yes, we tried to kill DP the first night but he was protected by a doc (ralphmerridew?). I had to send in a choice without being able to consult my mafia colleagues. In retrospect, I should have realised that a doc would protect a well known figure the first night.

The night Damelon got it, we had discussed killing either Zealot or Damelon. If we had gone for Zealot, the game may have gone differently!

I really had SK pegged for town until I was lynched. Then it became obvious that she was mafia. Hindsight is a wonderful thing. Well played, SK. And Zealot.

Great game. Thanks, OG, for modding. I think you did a great job. Well done to my mafia colleague, makemeok, for lasting until the very end.

[sketchwick]

quote:

---

Well played, SK. And Zealot.

Well done to my mafia colleague, makemeok, for lasting until the very end.

---

Mentat, you are very polite, but forget what your mother told you, I'd rather hear your criticism.

sketchwick

[makemeok]

not-so-well-done to Mentat for putting up such a feeble defense his last day.

[Zealot]

If anyone wants to know, HorseRiderMS investigated Neo, DP, mathgrant, and AFI, in that order. She got them all innocent, and only one was still alive when Neo wanted the cop to come out.

[Mentat]

??

[BrevITy]

SEE!!!!! You shouldn't've killed me!!!!!!!! I COULD'VE SAVED YOU!!!!

[Samadhi]

Good job Zealot.

[Samadhi]

Oh and SK too my bad.

[sketchwick]

I get the feeling a list of aliases would be helpful...

sketchwick

[PuzzleProdigy]

Sorry to not reply to your email OG, I have a new account.
DP was protected by Sparticus night 1.