WWE Mafia Game Thread GAME OVER

[wldhrtcgd99]

unvote for now. Gotta read.

[Blake Judge]

I'm immune to night kills. Happy? Now we've wasted the chance of the mafia/SK targeting me and losing a kill.

[wldhrtcgd99]

I don't buy that. Many Mafia GF have a chance to choose between being immune to night kills or being proven innocent by cops investigation. There are a lot of ways mafia have been given that.

[MNOWAX]

wow what unluckiness that has happened to this game.

Dutters has resigned from this game, due to personal reasons. i am taking this as if he were modkilled, due to all of the circumstances surrounding this game. i am also considering this day a No-Lynch because of this new devlopment and the game will go into night.


Dutters was "legitmately injured" and will be out for four to six months due to a torn Bicep. Therefore, he will no longer be participating in the Royal Rumble, or be in Wrestlemania. He was Randy Orton, Mafia RoleBlocker.


Get those choices in folks!


N00b mod gets all his troubles at once.
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[MNOWAX]

The next morning will be at Midnight tonight EST. i am still waiting on a couple of choices. thank you!
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[MNOWAX]

Welcome back everyone.

You all have woken up to find a person dead. Quailman, Sabu, is found right next to Josh-oo-wuh, who is sleeping soundly. He has had his legs broken off, presumably from a figure four leg lock. It looked like Sabu was trying to kill Josh, but to no avail.

Also, let it be known that wldhrtcgd99 is Jeff Hardy, and is nothing more than a confirmed Vanilla Townie

Quailman, Sabu, SK was killed by a Figure-Four leg lock.

With five people left it will take three to lynch! Get to it guys!
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[Livingod]

Ouch! At least we got the SK off of our backs. I wish Sabu were a vig, though. And not dead. Oh well, one scum down!
_________________
ScumTube!
Endless Mafia. Replacements constantly needed.

[Josh-oo-wuh]

I take it Ric Flair is mafia.

[Livingod]

Took me a while to look up that one. Either wikipedia is slow, or my web browsing skills suck. And it seems odd that haxxor would just point out that Sabu failed in his kill. If we go by standard rules, Sabu's death shouldn't inhibit his NK power, at least for that night. I'm thinking RB, doc, or maybe Josh has some power. Oh, and by the looks of it, there seems to be only one scum group left. Either one or two members. One, not much of a problem. Two, lylo...

Food for thought. I pointed this out Day 2 as well, but we got lucky with Dutters.
_________________
ScumTube!
Endless Mafia. Replacements constantly needed.

[theopholis]

[Josh-oo-wuh]

Since I've already claimed earlier in the game, I see no harm in telling you that I have no real abilities. So, I'm betting I was protected or Quailman was roleblocked. My bet is that someone has a bodyguard role and thus killed Sabu when he tried to kill me. If that's true, I think we truly are dealing with only one mafia group now. It's not definite, but I feel it's a decent guess. I'm not comfortable voting Judge, but I don't see who I should vote for yet.

[Livingod]

Hmm, a bodyguard does make sense. As it is too much of a coincidence that scum targeted the SK someone prevented the SK kill. I think either both the mafia and the SK kills were prevented via a doc/RB and bodyguard, respectively, or the SK was prevented via bodyguard and mafia just abstained from killing for some reason. Then again, it may not be a bodyguard. But if it were, then Ric Flair would be the bodyguard, no?

As for voting, I'm on my toes at this point, as a wrong vote could cause a scum wagon and cost us the game.
_________________
ScumTube!
Endless Mafia. Replacements constantly needed.

[Blake Judge]

This is very true. We've seen off one mafioso and one SK so far, so it seems likely that one or two scum remain. If it's the latter, we lose with a botched lynch.

Looking at scenarios for what could have happened last night, I can see the following:

1) Flair is a protector
2) Flair is scum and targeted Sabu
3) Flair is Josh's underling

Now, I find the third option hard to believe. Everything that Josh has said so far rings true, and the involvement of the Kane character (not scum) probably precludes any mafia group including Undertaker. The first two options are far more likely, IMO.

Another thing to throw into the mix is the fact that option 1 would make more sense if the scum tried to kill me, disbelieving my claim, and failed. The Flair bodyguard then killed Sabu as he attempted to take out Josh.

Two of these options have Flair as scum, and I also know that HHH is in the mafia. Dutters died and was Randy Orton, a mafioso. This leads me to believe that the mafia group is evolution, and that Flair probably is scum (although there could be a Batista character still.)

wldhrtcgd99 is cleared, so that leaves Josh, Livingod and theopholis. As stated, I trust Josh, so I'm left to decide between the last two. Livingod has seemed fairly reasonable but pressed me to reveal my ability, which I find suspicious. theopholis seemed eager to just 'get something going' yesterday, which strikes me as scummy. On balance I'm going to go with the guy who wants to lynch the character that can't die by other means:

Vote: theopholis

[Livingod]

Now, I believe that one of these two are scum. Why? because if it was town voting town, the scum would wagon. As for who is scum, right now, I'm leaning toward Theo. Simply because he voted first and risked a scum victory. Judge's vote is warranted and safe, since theo's vote was basically a "kill us, scum!" banner and a second one won't make a difference. Again, I'm hesitant to vote, but Big FoS: Theo
_________________
ScumTube!
Endless Mafia. Replacements constantly needed.

[Josh-oo-wuh]

I'm holding back my vote for now, but I want to do two things:

1) I second the FoS: theopholis.

2) I think there's something worth looking into with these Flair theories. I'm very close to asking Flair to step forward and reveal himself. I won't yet though, for if he's a bodyguard, he's too valuable to reveal.

[Livingod]

Where's wild?
_________________
ScumTube!
Endless Mafia. Replacements constantly needed.

[MNOWAX]

im prodding wld. if she doesn't respond in 48-72 hours, she will have to be replaced.

wow i have replaced that role once already.
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[Livingod]

Well, seeing as how Josh is the only other active non voting person. Josh:

Do you want to vote? Frankly I'm quite ready.
_________________
ScumTube!
Endless Mafia. Replacements constantly needed.

[Josh-oo-wuh]

What the hell, sure.

Let's put theo at lynch -1, see what happens.

Vote: theopholis

[theopholis]

Well well well. I wasn't surprised when BlakeJudge voted for me, but I am a bit surprised that two others among us have agreed with him.

[Livingod]

Hammah Time! -----[]

Nananananana Can't touch this!

Vote: theopholis

Lynch scene! Yaay!
_________________
ScumTube!
Endless Mafia. Replacements constantly needed.

[Livingod]

Btw, word in MS is that Wildheart99 had babies.
_________________
ScumTube!
Endless Mafia. Replacements constantly needed.

[MNOWAX]

thats kewl this thread is closed hold on.
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[MNOWAX]

Livingod , Josh-oo-wuh, and Blake Judge decide that It's time to get Theopholis. However, when they look for him, he is found in the middle of the ring. talking to the millions.......and millions of the Rock's fans. The three run to the ring, and try to take down Theo, but to no avail. Rock Bottom on all three! As Livingod, Josh, and Blake lie motionless in the ring, Theo gets up on the middle rope and says what every wrestling fan in the world wants to say: "If ya Smeeellllllll What the Rock Is Cookin'!!!"

Theopholis , The Rock, has been Lynch protected. Therefore, No-lynch was made.

It is now Night Four get your choices in ASAP

I will be looking for a replacement for Wild. I hope her baby is doing well.
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[MNOWAX]

Quailman, due to the fact he was a SK, he has no other knowledge of the inner workings of the game and will be able to replace wild.

Quail2 replaces Wild
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[MNOWAX]

Weclcome back everyone, well some of you, There are just four of you left.

Quailman, just having been replaced is dead again! he took a pedigree on to a steel chair.

With four left its three to lynch. Good luck!
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[Quailman]

bah!

[Livingod]

Hmm, So we have the following important* roles at our disposal currently:

Sabu, SK, killed once - DEAD
Triple H, most likely scum, killed twice (the last time a confirmed townie) - AT LARGE
Ric Flair, scum? bodyguard?, killed the SK (perhaps prevented the SK kill) - AT LARGE
The Rock, Theo, alignment unknown, lynch protected once - Quite blatantly AT LARGE

*important meaning the killing roles and the roles we know to be alive.

I bet I was wrong about the lylo earlier. Because if we had two mafia, we would have lost. But we're definetely at lylo now. This is most likely going to be the last day, soo mass roleclaim!
_________________
ScumTube!
Endless Mafia. Replacements constantly needed.

[theopholis]

OK. I am The Rock.

Now it's your turn.

An important point for me to make now is that it is quite possible I was wrong about the Blake Judge/Livingod mafia team. If that were true, it would be game over with only four players remaining. Stalemate/no lynch today and mafia kill tomorrow night. That is unless Josh has some sort of ability that could make a mafia lynch with only two townies possible today.

On the other hand, the setup as suggested by some other players who know more about the WWE than myself makes two remaining mafia roles seem like that's what we have.

This is all a bit confusing now. I was so happy with my argument, too. Well, chances are I'm at least 50% right on who the scum is, and I am leaning heavily in the direction of Livingod because of his manipulation of Josh into voting for me yesterday and for the level of glee he displayed when he cast the lynching vote on me after I had just called him out. It was exactly the sort of slip-up I was hoping the scum would make when casting the lynching vote. HUGE FOS and a People's Elbow on Livingod

[Josh-oo-wuh]

Since The Undertaker is dead, I, Kane, am now just a vanilla townie with no abilities. Sorry.

I second that motion on putting the screws to Livingod. Quite the happy hammerer is he.

In fact, start the pressure on!

Vote: Livingod

[Livingod]

Theo: Let's hear your roleclaim as well.


My partial claim:

I am THE Ric Flair.
I have (had) a bodyguard ability. I would choose who to protect every night until I actually picked a victim, whereupon I would kill the aggressor. I lost my ability after 1 protection, i.e. Josh. And after I read the night events post at daybreak, I noticed how it said that Josh was "sleeping soundly." I assumed him to be vanilla. That's why I directed all of my arguments at him, because I felt that he was the only person I can trust. (Although my assumption became moot when I realized that the scum didn't kill that night.)

My night choices were Night 1 Quailman and Night 2 Josh.

We know three characters to be alive:
The Rock - Theo (Mod confirmed)
Ric Flair - Me (will not be counterclaimed)
Triple H - Scum

We have two nameclaims that will not be verified because although they were not counterclaimed, we don't know that they even exist.

These are:
Kane - Josh (seeker, if I remember right)
Stone Cold - Blake (informed townie and immune to NKs, if I remember right)

At least one of them is lying.
_________________
ScumTube!
Endless Mafia. Replacements constantly needed.

[Josh-oo-wuh]

While the claim is logical, it seems too convenient, especially since I was the one to throw the bodyguard idea out there. I could be wrong, but I think there's already a strong case against Livingod.

[Livingod]

The case is the "speedlynch" essentially. When I asked you if you wanted to vote, I said:

[theopholis]

[Livingod]

The lynch-1 thing, yea, sorry. I mistook a HUGE FoS and People's Elbow as a vote. (They're both bold, you know)

Claimed Roles:
Theo - Lynch immune (has supporting evidence)
BJ - NK immune (no evidence, makes sense with Theo's role though)
Me - one shot bodyguard (has supporting evidence)
Josh - seeker, now vanilla (no evidence)

The more I think about it, the more a Josh vote makes sense.

Theo: http://mikeburnfire.sitesled.com/mscumB.swf Protective -> Bodyguard

Heehee, BJ sounds funny...
_________________
ScumTube!
Endless Mafia. Replacements constantly needed.

[MNOWAX]

vote count:

Josh-oo-wuh 1: (livingod)

Livingod 1: (josh-oo-wuh)

not voting 2: (blake judge, theopholis)
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[Blake Judge]

Well, we have one mafioso left or the game would be already over, so we need to look at scenarios for that. Most of the roleclaim information has already been posted, as well as the roles that we know to be out there. I don't see anything missing or incorrect there, and it's all very relevant.

As critical of me as theo has been, I find it hard to believe that he's scum at this point. The character, the role and general behaviour support that in my mind and he's bottom of my suspects list. Then there's Josh, who has struck me as trustworthy for most of the game. I'm not familiar with the Seeker role, but it definitely seems to make sense. I can't really think of a comprable scum role that he'd feel safe in modifying.

That leaves Livingod. As things stand, he's definitely at the top of my list because of the roleclaim. Nothing seems wrong about it, other than the convenience of it all. I'll throw a FoS: Livingod out there.

[Josh-oo-wuh]

I'd like to add that it seems that Livingod's vote for me seems to be out of a desire to eliminate his strongest critic.

Also, Judge made an excellent point in that we are certainly left with just one more scum player. Given who the mafia has consisted of so far, Flair would fit PERFECTLY with that group, while The Rock, Austin, and Kane would not.

Also, Livingod claims there is no evidence to support my roleclaim. I think that's an overstatement at best. There is hard evidence that someone else had The Undertaker role, and while that does not 100% prove my claim, I believe it gives it a great deal of substance.

This is in stark contrast to Livingod's claim of being Flair The Bodyguard. This is half supported, half not. The half that is supported is that he IS Flair. I truly believe we would have seen a counterclaim if he wasn't. However, he says there is evidence to support that he is a bodyguard. Now, there is such a role in the world of mafia, and we all now know that, THANKS TO ME. However, if I had never brought that up, I don't believe Livingod would have ever thought to make his present claim. Plus, while there is evidence that he killed Sabu, that is ALL there is evidence of - that he has a night kill ability of some sort. I believe it's simply far more likely statistically that he is scum, as opposed to town.

By the way, when he made his claim, he said it was a PARTIAL claim. What part did he leave out? Maybe a minor quibble, but something odd I noticed.

Given all of this, I have no reservations at all about lynching him now.

[Livingod]

[Blake Judge]

MNOWAX has informed me that the game is over.