Redwall Mafia Game Thread MAFIA WINS

[Courk]

Told y'all.

The way it played out the game didn't seem unbalanced. I haven't considered all possibilities, but that fact that everyone had a chance to win at the end is a good sign.

Small suggestion:
You fixed this towards the end of the game, but earlier you would just post "So-and-so dead." It's helpful for a quick reference back if you bold the important information, including the role, after your scene, so "So-and-so dead, doc."

Thank you for not forcing me to kill when I asked for clarification.

Thanks for a good game!

*is wondering if Zag has any questions*

[Zag]

Thanks, all, for a fun game.

I could see, Courk, that you were completely right, if MNO had only listened to you. If my story was correct, the town wins if you only vote no lynch, since I could kill you that night. I threw in a little support for ridicule (Sorry about that -- it was necessary.) and then just hoped MNO didn't read carefully. In fact, if you had talked him into it, I was going to kill shadow to give you the win, since I thought you would deserve it at that point and it seemed more in character of Cluny, to throw in with the Serial Killer rather than the town.

Anyone who bought that early nonsense, asking about rules and the like, clearly doesn't know me that well. I had clarified all those questions with UM before the game even started. My early plan was to do something to act a little suspicious, but then pass it off with newbiness and get a couple of you on my side. Unfortunately, I had no idea that supporting Loki's role claim request would come at me so strongly, since I figured any backlash would go at him. The possibility that he had been cleared by the cop never occurred to me, and I didn't know that such a request was as suspicious as it was.

I got out of some of it with good role-playing, which shouldn't have surprised MNOWAX, at the very least, since he was involved in the first role-playing game I ran, and had commented on the second. Plus I got lucky.

One thing UM didn't point out was that we were day-talking mafia, which actually helped a lot. Lamont and I had some long conversations, which included concluding early that Courk was a serial killer. Lamont still thought she might be a vigilante, but I've been quite sure of that since her first kill. I knew that there was no way there was a vigilante in that setup. I do have to admit that I first became suspicious because of the whole nonsense with raekuul -- I never saw his note, but the fact that it had existed meant that Courk had to be something interesting and not a normal townie. I realize that this was a bit of meta-gaming, but, as Cluny, cheating seemed ok.

Thanks, again, UM.

[Courk]

I wasn't completely trying to hide the fact I could kill, since I did want to claim Vig.

Actually, I had toyed with the idea of not killing on night 2, but decided to try for the doc so the cop could be killed. That would have hurt my vig argument, I spent all day saying we should no lynch, then turned around that night and kill someone.

[sAbLLimINal]

I surprised myself that I almost called both the mafia and sk roles (just a mix up between you two). Oh well, anyways thanks for a good game.

[Sniklac16]

This was a really good game UM...even though i died early on lol. But now that its over all should sign up for the game im modding.itll be great haha
_________________
What lies behind us and what lies before us are tiny matters compared to what lies within us.

[MNOWAX]

Wow...damn

I was SO sure Zag was town, and his story was plausible. It serves me right for allowing that to happen. I was afraid that my info that Courk was scum was not totally reliable( i got a scum result on her, but wasn't totally sure if that meant SK or Maf).

GG everyone, sorry that went so south, and THanks for Modding UM!
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[Zag]

Heh heh heh.

Don't beat yourself up. As I said, if you HAD listened to her, I was going to throw the game to her, so the town had no chance at that point.