LOST mafia - Game Thread - GAME OVER!

[Nauplius]

[Narninian]

it seems to be either MNOWAX or Pete D HAVE to be scum as one of them is lying ---

I really dont like Pete's claim as it means he's a bloodthirsty Vig that wants me dead - and he seems eager to use his powers.

but if MNOWAX is telling the truth --- what the heck is Pete D? He's gotta be lying -- and liars are usually scum, but if he targetted me and is scum -- what does that mean?

for now UNVOTE: Pete D

[Narninian]

One thing I can think of that would make MNOWAX's story make sense is if Pete D was a Mafia cop of some sort. He investigated me and now he wants me dead. If he cant get me lynched then he can have me killed and its justified because he told the town he'd do so ahead of time.

[Cephrir]

Unvote pete d.
I think MNOWAX is lying, but I'm not positive. Also, the only ways I can see that both MNOWAX and Pete D could be town would be: One is lying about their claim (I have no idea why) or Pete D tried to vig Narninian, who was doc-protected, which did not show up in the dayscene for some odd reason. The first is much more likely, obviously, but I don't believe either is the case.
FoS: MNOWAX.

[pete d]

apparently I don't leave until tomorrow. sorry about that.

unvote, vote: MNOWAX

if he is not lynched today, you can be certain that I will target him tonight.

see you guys in a week.

[Narninian]

I have an alternate plan. We don't lynch MNOWAX or Pete D. One of them is lying, so assuming a town member isn't lying then one of them is scum. I think we should let them both live until night, and then have Pete D kill mnowax --- if he turns up town we know that pete d was lying (or isnt killed) and we can lynch him.

[MNOWAX]

i am not trying to get pete d lynched. i am only bringing this up because i know he's lying about something. Wether hes a vig or a SK or scum or a townie non killing role that is just as powerful is what i am after. it is my intent to find out who pete d really is. Pete D might not be scum, i jsut know what my info is. Like i said before he targetted Narnian, not yamahako. i don't know what this means at all, but if it means i have to risk dying tonight to prove anything then i will. It will be for the good of the town. I just dont think that he kills, and hes lying about his vig role.
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[Primate]

vote Mnowax

What we have here is a really easy 1-1 trade at worst, plus we have the with the numbers to make it work. It's not as if its anything remotely subjective either, it's tracker vs someone disagreeing with tracker, and it's hard to come up with a serious reason as to how any mafia could screw with that. Regardless of which way we look at it, without anyone counterclaiming the kill on Yama, he cannot be an SK leeching off the kill of a vig. This means that either he is a lying scum leeching off the SK or vise versa (we get 1-1). 1 distinctly odd possibilty is that he is scum leeching off the kill of the other scum, and Mnowax is the other scum group, gifted with the knowledge that Pete D is lying. Whilst this would be hilarious, it doesn't really change our plan for today, so y'know. So, anyway what I'm really getting at is that there's little chance that PD is the vig-masquarading SK of legend, the dude that if we lynch him will drop our kills unless mnowax is also scum, making the retconning Mnowax the better lynch in this case.

@Narnian: A single scum RB fucks your plan, and they're more than common enough for me to feel apprehensive. Not to mention the fact that it simply isn't as efficient unless we have someone else we need to get rid of as well, which we don't really atm.

[Narninian]

Pete D has admitted he's going to kill me or MNOWAX so Ill admit Im kind of apprehensive to letting us go to night without an alternate target for Pete D. So even if we decide MNOWAX is the one to lynch I think we should discuss that first.

We have to decide between a claimed tracker, and a Claimed Vigilante thats killed already. Who you believe aside --- the tracker is much more valuable to keep alive in my opinion. If we decide to lynch him anyway, the town should really give recommendations for pete on who to kill -- we can use him as an extra lynch rather than an extra person to fear.

[Primate]

If hypothetical PeteDvig targets you, he really isn't paying enough attention.

If Mnowax turns up scum, mista vig has free reign, as vigs should do. If he doesn't, there's no controlling him, as he's scum.

[Green Crayons]

[Nauplius]

[Nauplius]

I didn't see Green Crayons post when I made that last post. That just leaves Rathyr.

[ChannelDelibird]

Yeah, I'm comfortable with a vote: MNOWAX. Kate is almost certainly in the game (although I'll admit vig is strange), and Walt was absent for long periods...
_________________
The CDB Desk blog

[Narninian]

Its true Kate is more likely to be in the game than Walt. I can't see reasoning for Walt being a tracker, but I think its really a stretch for Kate being a VIG. Maybe they are both lying? But I agree with consensus here --- MNOWAX is a good pick. lets see if Rathr has anything to say.

[Nauplius]

I guess we won't hear from Rathyr. If I'm counting correctly Green Crayon's vote was the lynch vote and ChannelDelibird's was just overkill.

[Primate]

[filibuster]

Oh how I have been neglecting you, oh faithful lostees.

You gather at the gallows and hoist MNOWAX up to the noose.

He struggles. One of the town grabs him by the shoulders while someone else grabs him by the hair and beard.

"Wait a sec..."

"This isn't even a real beard!"

"Who the hell are you?"

MNOWAX just glowers.

MNOWAX was Tom, AKA Mr. Friendly, an OTHER.

Town, you're doing very well. In fact, you're ruining my game.

Get me some night choices!!
_________________
I not only think that we will tamper with your mother's nature. I think your mother wants us to.

[filibuster]

I'm still waiting on [no/one/some/all] night choice[/s] from [none/one/several/all] of you.

C'mon [ladies/gentlemen]!
_________________
I not only think that we will tamper with your mother's nature. I think your mother wants us to.

[filibuster]

In 24 hours, I open this thread. I want the last of the night choices.
_________________
I not only think that we will tamper with your mother's nature. I think your mother wants us to.

[filibuster]

Day dawns to find a distinct lack of flavor in the opening post.

And two dead bodies! Both shot by person or persons or (super-intelligent-cyborg-polar-bears) unknown.

Narninian was Jack Shephard, doctor. Sadly, he couldn't self-protect or he would be with us today.

Cephrir is found dead outside Primate's tent. What was he doing there? Presumably following tracks. Cephrir was John Locke, tracker.

With six alive, it is four to lynch.

Goodbye. And good luck!
_________________
I not only think that we will tamper with your mother's nature. I think your mother wants us to.

[Primate]

Vote Rathyr

Get er done.

BTW, I have no idea what that morning scene thing is about. I intend to claim today anyway.

Fos Pete D For missing the blatantly obvious fact that Narnian was a doc.

[ChannelDelibird]

I assume Narninian was pete d's kill.

Mod: could we have a prod on Rathyr? He's disappeared on mafiascum too as far as I can tell, so I think this is more general inactivity than specific lurking in this game.
_________________
The CDB Desk blog

[Narninian]

BAH

powerless to stop it.

[Green Crayons]

[Primate]

I'd quite like Rathyr replaced, if it's not too much trouble. His last post on 'scum was Dec 18, and that was in a game he didn't request replacement in. Also, he's todays primary lynch possiblty, so it's not like we can get by with a couple of posts by him.

@GC: you're probly right about that.

[filibuster]

wldhrtcgd99 has offered to replace Rathyr, effective as soon as she confirms her role.
_________________
I not only think that we will tamper with your mother's nature. I think your mother wants us to.

[wldhrtcgd99]

She's confirmed! I've got some reading to do.

[pete d]

i thought that due to me being able to kill every night, as well as the amount of power roles, that there could be a SK (or more than one scum killing group). but the possible other killer would have most likely had to attack me, as Narnian probably protected me. or there is a RB. (there are a lot of power roles).

it looks pretty obvious that their is still 1 (at least) mafioso alive. I think that it is CDB. Livingod wagon: he is the 2nd last vote, when it was inevitable that livingod would be lynched. MNOWAX wagon: he puts on an overkill vote. 2 distancing votes for 2 mafiosos. He also was the first to place blame me on day 2. vote: ChannelDelibird.

the good news is, we probably still have a sane cop.

[Primate]

[ChannelDelibird]

[Primate]

[ChannelDelibird]

[Primate]

I think we should mass claim, personally.

I mean, we need to make sure this is the correct lynch, and I very much doubt that there's gonna be four mafioso's who can take advantage of the fact that all our roles are out in the open. Better to get everything out there and make sure we dont fuck up.

About the only wildcard left is Pete D, and we can keep him on the leash easily enough. He doesn't do what we say and we kill him. Fairly easy.

[pete d]

unvote

[Nauplius]

I have no problem with mass claiming, but I want to see what wldhrtcgd99 claims first. I'd also like to see night choices from pete d and Primate.

[wldhrtcgd99]

Well, do you guys want my claim or my thoughts?

[MNOWAX]

might be a little late, but , BAH! Go Others!
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[ChannelDelibird]

[Primate]

My N1 was Yamahako.