Vanilla Mafia Game Thread [Phoenix dead - Day 3]

[isauteikisa]

I don't feel it's necessary, but fair enough.

unvote

This vote goes back on in 24 hours unless I've got a damn good reason to change it.
_________________
[VXCL] 075-1DR
I'm male, people.

[thedragon'sprincess]

alright I've read through and I definately get a major scum vibe from leonidas. Why continue to vote someone we know to be innocent?
vote: leonidas

[Leonidas]

Don't bother.

Mafia: I told you that there was no need for this to become horrible. I also asked you to surrender. Now, you're pretty much stuck with isau and MNOWAX. Good luck. Anyway - we did share a... moment.

Ms. Lovett - it's been a priviledge to play with you, and I look forward to doing so again in the near future.

unvote, vote: Leonidas

[thedragon'sprincess]

uhhh wow what just happened?

[wordcross]

And with six votes, the lynch mob drags leonidas limply to the gallows. Leo, facing his accusers with a defiant stare, says nothing as the noose is fitted around his neck. He quickly denounces his opponents, and those are his last words.

Certain of their victory, the town converges on his home, busting down the door and ransacking the house.

Oddly enough, though, the thorough trashing turns up no evidence of foul play. No weapons, no tools, no money, no drugs...

Leo was innocent!

Horrified, the people of the town turn fearful. Night is falling, and the mafia is still fully intact. Who of you will fall this night? What will the morning bring?
_________________
Has anyone really been far even as decided to use even go want to do look more like?

[wordcross]

Any of you with night abilities please PM me your targets. Please do not post in the thread during the night phase.

Choose wisely.
_________________
Has anyone really been far even as decided to use even go want to do look more like?

[Wall-E]

*eating popcorn*
_________________
Don't read what I'm typing!

[wordcross]

As the sun rises over the town, its inhabitants wake and tentatively make their way towards town hall. Each of the innocent ones knows that their life has been spared this night, but they also know that someone didn't make it.

The mafia already knows, but as everyone arrives at the steps of Town Hall, the death of Dragon Phoenix is made clear, his bullet-ridden body sprawled on the steps before them. His officer's uniform is stained with blood, and his service revolver is gone. Looks like the town has lost yet another stalwart defender.

8 players left

5 to lynch.

Alive: 8
AZu
ditchdoc
Dragon's Princess
HPew
isauteikisa
MNOWAX
Ms. Lovett
Undercover Monk
_________________
Has anyone really been far even as decided to use even go want to do look more like?

[AZu]

Suprise,suprise. Well it looks like the town is in some deep trouble. I think I will avoid revealing my investigation results.

[Leonidas]

(Rolling on the floor laughing all the way to his shrink. )

[MNOWAX]

well that just confirmed something for me. I was wondering which one of the three was scum.

I am the other cop, not aZu. it pisses me off that Leo opened his mouth about me being a cop, but he was right.

I investigated aZu last night as well to confirm it, but with DP dying, it confirmed itself. This isn't the way i wanted to get scum, but it is looking like you guys will have to do it without me, it is almost certain that i will die tonight, but at least we got one.
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[AZu]

It's lynch or lose, so it costs him nothing to make a false cop claim.

If I were scum I would have had no reason to claim cop yesterday and save DP.

Vote MNOWAX

From my point of view he is obviously scum so I am voting him but I would advise the rest of the town to be very careful about who they vote. One wrong vote and the sum can pile on the votes and we lose.

[MNOWAX]

vote aZu

i guess i shouldn't be surprised. its LYLO, and he is the first to vote. waiting for your other scum buddies to jump on? or are they just going to wait for some more townies to jump on me?
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[Ms. Lovett]

Who did you investigate the other night, MNOWAX?

Wow, damn, and I had been so sure that DP had been lying too.

@Leo in post 283: *gives a post-mortem salute* and I did enjoy playing with you as well sir.

[MNOWAX]

Hpew he is innocent
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[AZu]

[Undercover Monk]

Man this sucks I want to kill Leo again just for causing this situation. My gut says to go with AZu cause MNO and Hpew both were on the DP wagon. They would have known that DP was a cop if they were scum but Id like to hear AZu's investigation first.
_________________
The Classic Blunders:
1. never get involved in a land war in Asia
2.Never go in against a Sicilian when DEATH is on the line
3. Never release Peyton Manning

[AZu]

Unfortunately I investigated MNOWAX last night, so we aren't getting any further information from there. I didn't forsee this gambit and figured we would be focusing on Ms Lovet (whom I find extremely suspicious).

[HPew]

Yay, I'm confirmed innocent. Gah! Although I does allow me to say, without it being concealed scum gloating: What a screw up of D2. Both annoying loud-mouths were wrong.

[AZu]

[MNOWAX]

youre damn right i was on the DP wagon. However, this was Day 1 when we had a lot less to go on then we do now. When aZu claimed cop as well , i knew at least one was scum. i wasn't going to buss myself when we figured that one cop was pretty much dead last night. However i wasn't sure who was scum. i said way before this i wasn't sure about DP. check out the posts during day 2 for him, and in regards to the entire Leo DP situation.
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[MNOWAX]

[HPew]

[AZu]

Well it seems that we have caught ourselves another scum. HPew's feeble attempts to defend MNOWAX only serve to reveal him for what he is : scum.

[AZu]

As far as MNOWAX is concerned he is obviously lying. If he were truly a cop then the moment I claimed cop yesterday he would have known I was scum. As I pointed out at the time it would be impossible for DP to be scum and me not; I claimed to investigate DP and get townie, so if I was townie so was DP. Now MNOWAX being supposedly the other cop would have known that we cant both be cops and that consequently I was scum.

And what does he do? Nothing, he sits back and lets us lynch an innocent man. He said that he did it to protect himself but we already knew that DP was going down last night so he was safe for last night and he subsequently (supposedly) outed himself this morning, so effectively he has protected himself from nothing. So that argument doesn't hold.

Not only did he not speak up and brought us to a lynch or lose situation. Not only did he falsely state that he did it to protect himself which is obviously a bunch of crap but when asked who he investigated last night he said me. Me? Who he would have known already to be scum ? Why would waste an investigation like that?

Because he is lying. Plain and simple.

[HPew]

[AZu]

At this points if any of the townies actually believes MNOWAX's claim or actually finds anything intelligent in HPew's last posts then we deserve to lose.

[MNOWAX]

[Undercover Monk]

Ummm Hpew why are you voting a confirmed innocent. DP cleared me before he died. Also I hate being called a liar MNOWAX was on the Day 2 bandwagon of DP!
_________________
The Classic Blunders:
1. never get involved in a land war in Asia
2.Never go in against a Sicilian when DEATH is on the line
3. Never release Peyton Manning

[Undercover Monk]

[Undercover Monk]

Also Ive looked at AZU's proof and it seems logical (follow me):

If MNOWAX is Cop:
* Then when Azu claims he has to decide if he believes him. So he has two choices
a.)Azu is innocent and a cop:
This means that when he claims DP has been confirmed he is telling the truth and we then have three cops. MNOWAX"S assumption of Azu= cop disproves MNO= cop


b.) Azu is scum
since he can not trust AZU in this assumption he must look at two more scenarios DP innocent and DP guilty. (this is before DP was killed and assuming he has not checked DP as of yet.)

1.)DP is innocent and a cop
This means Azu (being scum) knows DP is innocent and therefore a cop can now bandwagon the cop quite easily or back the cop and try to draw out the cop. That last one is the only thing keeping MNOWAX Cleared and Ill look at that in just a minute. But I acknowledge that in a minute.

2.)DP is scum (again this is before DP was killed so MNO had to deal with this situation)
Azu comes in with a save of his scum buddy which means MNO has a possible two scum in his hands but cant be sure of either.in this assumption.


Summary: If MNO is a cop AZU is guilty and DP may or may not be. Why keep quiet? Unless he had checked DP he has a responsibility to out Azu in case DP and AZU are scum running the town and he does nothing. So maybe he checked DP, knows hes innocent, and doesnt want to give AZu the last cop, but then why vote DP when he keeps coming close to lynch (its not till AZu claims that MNO switches). A good cop may not give up the innocent name but he never pushes him toward lynch. So we must assume MNO didnt know what DP was. And he does nothing! I dont buy it a cop with two other unconformed claimed cops has to do something.

MNOWAX 90% chance of being scum
Hpew 80% chance of being scum (for his defense of MNO)

Can anyone (even MNO or Hpew) see a flaw in my logic

Mod: Can we get some prods
I refuse to let this game die also! not when we have scum cornered.
_________________
The Classic Blunders:
1. never get involved in a land war in Asia
2.Never go in against a Sicilian when DEATH is on the line
3. Never release Peyton Manning

[wordcross]

Players who have not posted in day 3 have been prodded.



5 to lynch.

Total Votes: 3
MNOWAX: 1 [AZu]
AZu: 1 [MNOWAX]
Undercover Monk: 1 [HPew]

Yet to Vote: 5
ditchdoc
Dragon's Princess
isauteikisa
Ms. Lovett
Undercover Monk
_________________
Has anyone really been far even as decided to use even go want to do look more like?

[isauteikisa]

@AZu - you claim cop, but fail to reveal your investigation results when you know you're going to get killed? That sounds very much like scum 'holding back' information for a last second attempt at a lynch deflection. I'm holding off on voting right now, to give everything a better read and sort things out, but I'm not liking the situation.

FoS: AZu
_________________
[VXCL] 075-1DR
I'm male, people.

[isauteikisa]

Correction, fail to EXPLICITLY state early what your results were. Better reading helps, isau.

HPew, clear your vote on UM or my vote is headed your way. Might be headed there anyway.
_________________
[VXCL] 075-1DR
I'm male, people.

[Ms. Lovett]

[Undercover Monk]

agreed on the lurker point

I just feel that Hpew behavior is kinda condemming of MNO. Even when DP cleared me I was hesitant to throw ALL my support his way since the mafia know exactly who is and who isnt innocent. IDK this is a very risky situation.

I think both MNO and AZu should give us their investigation results and I would like a response on my logic by MNOWAX, please.
_________________
The Classic Blunders:
1. never get involved in a land war in Asia
2.Never go in against a Sicilian when DEATH is on the line
3. Never release Peyton Manning

[MNOWAX]

[isauteikisa]

vote: HPew
_________________
[VXCL] 075-1DR
I'm male, people.

[Ms. Lovett]

Hpew, I would unvote UM before you get a serious bandwagon on your hands. I think it might just be a mistake, cause what self-respecting scum would vote a confirmed innocent; and if he was such uber-obvscum, then I think he would have been giving more tells before this. But it still is damned suspicious, enough for me to place my vote on you unless you explain yourself.

[DitchDoc]

AZu, who did you investigate last night?

My vote for now is Hpew, he looks the scummiest. Going after UM, a confirmed innocent, by a known cop looks very scummy. It appears you are taking the light off of your scum buddy, either AZu or MNOWAX.

It would be nice to hear from Dragon Princess.