Johnny Depp Mafia: [Game Over]

[Sniklac16]

Ok first off only reason I posted at night was because other people were posting too, and it was said that you can post until the thread was locked which is why Amb gave me a second chance. To answer your question Mackay, I guess i didnt completely know that raekuul was mafia, just had a very good hunch, but i suppose I shouldnt say "i knew it" so I apologize for that.

Also if you're a jester you win the game if you're lynched, but lose if killed any other way.
_________________
What lies behind us and what lies before us are tiny matters compared to what lies within us.

[Chaz]

From MafiaWiki on Jester Mafia

[Mackay]

It's a role whose sole win condition is to be lynched, ending the game. It's pretty much defunct by now, because it's really easy to get lynched. I ignored it because I can't see amb using one, and you've already claimed vanilla town.

I'm aware that Snik is inexperienced, and it's why I argued against the lynch of his original incarnation day 1 (weren't you pushing for his lynch then, though? Odd to start caring about his experience level now). This time, he's saying things which sound evasive/defensive instead of just clueless, and honestly his behaviour and mannerisms have changed enough since night that I can't help but think he's been groomed by a caring scumbuddy or two. The fact that he spoke as though certain that you were mafia helps, too, but I'll be more happy with your lynch if we had a guilty Snik lynch first. I'm less scared to vote you now, though.

[Chaz]

But what did you post at night Snik?

Also, in the rules I linked you to (in post 220: http://greylabyrinth.com/discussion/viewtopic.php?p=487288#487288) It specifically says.... Huh... I'll be dammed... it doesn't say anything about night talking, nor does the first page of this thread.

Let me check Amb's "night has fallen posts"... Nope. Nothing. Am I just not seeing where it says "no night talking?"
_________________
The enemy's base is down.

[Mackay]

Didn't see Chaz' post before I replied.

Well...

...

I'm confused.

Honestly it seems like a pretty safe lynch. He has only shown signs of wanting to be lynched today, and he's claimed two separate roles. Like I said, I can't imagine Amb using one, and it seems like he is desperately flailing now. Probably in an attempt to distract from the fact that Snik pointed out that he knows Chaz is mafia.

I need to think about this first, though. All I know is that I definitely don't believe the "jester" claim.

[Chaz]

[Dragon Phoenix]

I am not going to invest oodles of time in this game in my current situation but I really do NOT see the Chaz lynch right now, as counter productive as his play has been. And if he and I were both scum, I would gladly throw him under the train right now.

Vote Sniklac16

Nothing that has happened recently has changed my mind about him.
_________________
My photography:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/artrock2006/

[Chaz]

Unvote; vote: Dragon Phoenix.

Clearly he is scum.
_________________
The enemy's base is down.

[Chaz]

So... Undercover Monk said his vote was on me, right?

unvote; Vote: Chaz I'm pretty sure that means that I'm lyched (if amb allows self lynching, and if Monk's vote actually counts.

So, I should be strung up now laughing at you townies trying to figure out who the last mafia could be. Is it Mackay? DP? who oh who oh who.

(It's Silverfire, rm, and Mackay.) Kill them.
_________________
The enemy's base is down.

[Chaz]

I wonder what rm and Silverfire will make of this. They must have known that i would go out with a bang... I wonder if they hesitated on killing Zag last night. I bet they would have if they could have read my crazy posts in advance. They're awfully quiet lately huh?
_________________
The enemy's base is down.

[Amb]

Vote Count
Chaz 4: Quailman, Sniklac16, MNOWAX, Chaz
Sniklac16 2: Mackay, Dragon Phoenix

Not voting: ralphmerridew, Silverfire, Undercover Monk

5 to lynch.

[Quailman]

Are you guys actually listening to this raving lunatic? Chaz today, Snik tomorrow. If there's a fourth Mafia, which I doubt, we deal with that the next day.

[Chaz]

I agree with Quail again.

Provided we don't lynch Snik when Chaz comes up as townie...

Though, after thinking about it last night and this morning, I'm not sure that leaving the fate of town in the hands of MNO and Snik is the brightest idea. Hopefully they'll listen to Quail (or, possibly DP or Mackay) and Snik can keep from getting mod killed long enough to lynch Silver.
_________________
The enemy's base is down.

[Chaz]

I am VERY curious about which order the night kills will happen in. I think I shall PM Amb after my lynching, just to see if I guess right. =D
_________________
The enemy's base is down.

[ralphmerridew]

If Chaz were telling the truth about being a Jester, he fouled it up with his role claim. He could have claimed a role not played by Johnny Depp. Making a role claim at random would almost certainly be nonthematic.

Hammer: Chaz

[Chaz]

Finally. Now kids, don't let that dissuade you.

On the off chance that the mafia team isn't Silver, rm, [rae], and Mackay. Congrats on a very well played game.

Also, @Amb, this was, by far, the most fun I've ever had playing mafia. =D
_________________
The enemy's base is down.

[Chaz]

If it were me still alive (as town)... I would lynch: Silverfire, then rm, then Mackay. I'm about 98% sure on SIlver, about 85% sure on rm (maybe more now that he hammered me) and only about 70% on Mackay,

The night kills should give you more info, but watch for the wine in front of you when considering who got night killed.
_________________
The enemy's base is down.

[Amb]

The town gathers around Chaz.

"I'm a jester! I win if you lynch me. Vote Chaz" he yells. The town, more worried about drowning in the spittle from his excited yells, decide that it is still his time regardless of the risk.

And before long, Chaz's lifeless body hung from the ropes. And then silence. Blessed silence...

And somewhere in the afterlife, Chaz, J M Barrie, Townie can look back and wonder if he made the right move.

Night falls. 72 hours

If you night post, you may be modkilled.

[Amb]

Approximately 24 hours left.

[Amb]

The town arose and admired the beautifully cut hedges. Gorgeously trimmed and cut to varying creative shapes. But sadly, those designs would be no more, for the town had lost the topiarist. Mackay, Edward Scissorhands, Town, has been beheaded

There are 7 alive, it will take 4 to lynch.

[Mackay]

Kinda glad I don't have to deal with the aftermath of Chaz sabotaging the game and ruining it for the rest of us anyway.

Have fun, guys. If you can.

*dies*

[MNOWAX]

[Sniklac16]

Crap he actually was town...I dont understand why hed play the game the way he did if he was town. Guess Ill have to take his advice then and try vote rm
_________________
What lies behind us and what lies before us are tiny matters compared to what lies within us.

[ralphmerridew]

Well, when this game ends, I really want to hear what Chaz was thinking yesterday.

Sniklac16: You are seriously listening to someone who was jumping around that heavily?

[MNOWAX]

He's scum. He wants someone lynched that is a townie.
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[Sniklac16]

omg im not scum i've already claimed....so instead of lynching another townie why dont we try and lynch the real scum
_________________
What lies behind us and what lies before us are tiny matters compared to what lies within us.

[Dragon Phoenix]

[Undercover Monk]

Post cruise recap as I read

Post 505(Chaz): wow Chaz nice try. It almost worked on me and made me doubt my auto vote I promised. Why would a scum vote themselves? To make us stop and think twice. (Oh he really is wanting the town to win cause he is willing to sacrifice himself). The thing is this is not day 1 randomn info gathering lynch nor is it a numbers game. We found one scum and I personally feel very strongly about a MNO lynch. However then I remembered why we are all voting for you. NO TOWNIE EVER OUTS THE SHERIFF. So yeah Nice Try.

Post 520(Macay): well at least someone has finally realized the danger MNO poses. I am not sure of Snick mostly because I haven’t reviewed his posts. I think Quails “ploy” comment was the same thing I realized. Doing something unexpected is the only way Chaz is going to make it out of the day. (a townie would be more concerned about other suspicious people instead of ridiculous self votes)

Post 557 (Sniclac16): so if you were scum you wouldn’t bus your obviously exposed scum buddy. This is so ridiculous its almost not a scum tell. What is horribly condemming is your adoption of MNOWAX as the next best lynch. You are too eager to please. Townies are not afraid to ruffle feathers. (The only noticeable townie trait Chaz has shown consistently). You have just moved up to at least 3rd on my list. Also what was your claim again????


Post 578 (Amb): Well crap I was hoping we hadn’t gone to night as I read. We were developing several good discussions. @MNOWAX the mafia didn’t kill Macay cause he was a talker they killed him cause he was confirmed townie duh. That was in part why I hadn’t posted a vote yet. Macay was insightful and I had several questions for him. But unfortunately while he was being killed by the scum I was singing karaoke and eating at buffets. =)

So some questions to all non-Macay participants
1. Snick would you describe yourself as inexperienced and what was your claim?
2. MNOWAX have you read my case against you and do you have a response
3. rm why did you hammer Chaz when you did. It seems suspicious that you hammer a defenseless Chaz when he was pointing at you as scum?
4. Quailman I haven’t paid much attention to you but with the death of heavy posters Zag, Chaz, and Macay we need info. Who are your top 3 scum candidates and why?

Sorry I couldn’t post til now.
_________________
The Classic Blunders:
1. never get involved in a land war in Asia
2.Never go in against a Sicilian when DEATH is on the line
3. Never release Peyton Manning

[raekuul]

I'm using my post-death post to point out that Mackay's a female. Great. Mackay, can't you put that sort of thing in your sig?

[MNOWAX]

what is your case against me? that I am scummy becuase i played a little different in this game?

*twirls finger in the air*

big whoop. My main issue is that I have had to change my style due to all of Chaz's leading. If i tried to compete with his post count, i would have been totally drowned out. Trust me you'll hear a lot more form me now that Caz is gone.
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[Quailman]

I just have a moment to remind you that I am gone until Tuesday. I will post more then.

Like the rest of you (except the scum), I can't believe Chaz was town. Pretty sure about Snik, but not ready to vote or reply to UM yet.

[ralphmerridew]

UM: I hammered Chaz on the "Lynch All Liars" principle and because he was continually acting in an anti-town manner.

[Amb]

Just a prod on the game to keep it going.

[Sniklac16]

ok lets get this game moing guys...and to answer your question UM my role is im Axel Blackmar townie
_________________
What lies behind us and what lies before us are tiny matters compared to what lies within us.

[Quailman]

My Internet connection has been wonky since I got home yesterday. I need to reread some, especially Chaz's posts that I had ignored since he was so clearly scum. If I had to vote now it would be Snik, for whom I was voting before.

[Amb]

Prods have been sent out for all players.

Deadline set at 7 days

[Dragon Phoenix]

Vote stays.
_________________
My photography:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/artrock2006/

[Quailman]

I don't want to rush like yesterday. I'm confident that Snik is scum, but I'd like to see more discussion so we can figure who else is scum. Right now I'm leaning toward MNOWAX. The next vote puts Snik at L-1, I think.

[Quailman]

Any sign of Silverfire?

[Silverfire]

*Sigh* I'm here, but I really don't know how to proceed, as so far the the townies have seemed eager to hurt the town and get themselves killed. I guess my greatest suspicion lies with MNOWAX, but deep down I'm afraid he might just be a crazy townie like Chaz was. In post 590 he hinted that he might have played the same way as Chaz if not for Chaz fulfilling that role.