Johnny Depp Mafia: [Game Over]

[MNOWAX]

I give up. I have mis read this game so bad and after Chaz not being scum, Macaky not being scum, and even my "confirmed scum" was town, I have not a clue.

I'm legitimately next to lynch , and since we are pretty much in LYLO GG scum.

Vote MNOWAX
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[Quailman]

If there are two remaining scum and you are not one of them, you just gave away the game.

I will be unavailable from tomorrow noon (my time) until Monday evening. Should I go ahead and vote or wait see what anyone else wants to speculate about the third scum? I have no idea, but strongly suspect rm at this point.

[Undercover Monk]

I can not see a townie voting themselves at this point I have wanted to vote MNOWAX since day 2. So until otherwise noted Vote:MNOWAX
_________________
The Classic Blunders:
1. never get involved in a land war in Asia
2.Never go in against a Sicilian when DEATH is on the line
3. Never release Peyton Manning

[MNOWAX]

Unvote, Vote UM
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[MNOWAX]

So its Quail and UM, Wow, I am quite surprised. Now I can only hope that the other two townies will show up enough to lynch you both.
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[Quailman]

vote: MNOWAX

I was going to say nice try, but it was pretty weak. If we were both scum I would have voted right behind UM and the game would be over. No townie would be so bold as to put the game on the line like you did.

[MNOWAX]

Yay! I WAS right

I feel a little redeemed now.
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[Silverfire]

Vote: MNOWAX

Goodbye.

[Amb]

MNOWAX lay dead, lynched. A quick search of his body showed a raft of golden tickets. Tickets to his wonderous, but about to be shut down, chocolate factory. MNOWAX, Townie, Willy Wonka was lynched.

ralphmerridew and Silverfire, the Public Enemies mafia, then turned on the survivors and took them each out. They never even needed the town traitor, Jack Sparrow who sat waiting to claim the extra chair.

Mafia win

[Zag]

Congrats, Mafia and Chaz, for the victory.

[Quailman]

WTF? How could a townie rationally vote for himself when it's lynch-or-lose?

And the mafia should thank Chaz for his help.

[raekuul]

Yes, thank you Chaz and MNOWAX for all the help you gave us!

[Quailman]

And thanks, amb! This was a great concept for a game, and well-thought-out, even if it didn't work out in my favor. You said there was a traitor. Was it Chaz or MNOWAX?

[Dragon Phoenix]

Thanks for running this amb. The less said about the town's performance (including mine) the better.
_________________
My photography:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/artrock2006/

[Chaz]

Oh man I rocked this game! =D

I even called the night kills of Mackay and DP.

[Zag]

[MNOWAX]

Wow waht a horrendous misplay by me. I thought At the very least I would have picked up a scum trying to quick lynch me. Its a tough gambit to play, but I think I shouldn't have played it now looking back on it. There was too many skeptics of me. I failed miserbly . Sorry Town, GG scum.

THank you Amb for Modding! this was hilarious fun! Who was Sparrow?
_________________
The Man The Myth The Legend
MNOWAX

[Amb]

Dear ralphmerridew,

You are Sweeny Todd, leader of the "Public Enemies" mafia group. Your goal is to outnumber the town by whatever means possible.

You have two fellow helpers to aid you on the way:
George Jung (Silverfire) and John Dillinger (Kraddrol)
You may only communicate directly during night phases.

Each night, pick a person you want to see killed. Each day, try to avoid being lynched.

Good luck,
Amb
------------------------------
Dear Silverfire,

You are George Jung, a member of the "Public Enemies" mafia group.

Sweeny Todd (ralphmerridew) is your GodFather, and John Dillinger is your co-hench man.You may only communicate directly during night phases.

Your goal is to outnumber the town by whatever means possible. Each night, pick a person you want to see killed. Each day, try to avoid being lynched.

Good luck,
Amb
------------------------------
Dear Kraddrol,

You are John Dillinger, a member of the "Public Enemies" mafia group.

Your goal is to outnumber the town by whatever means possible. As a team each night, pick a person you want to see killed. Each day, try to avoid being lynched.

Your team mates are Sweeny Todd (ralphmerridew) who is your GodFather and George Jung (silverfire)You may only communicate directly during night phases.

Good luck,
Amb
------------------------------
------------------------------
Dear Undercover Monk,

You are Captain Jack Sparrow. But are you town or evil? You have no idea and could swing either way. By default you are on the town side and will win with the town if they do. If this situation changes, you will get a PM from me with further details. You currently have no night abilities.

Good luck,
Amb
-------------------------------
Dear Chaz,

You are J M Barrie, author of Peter Pan. You are on the side of the town, and win with them.

Good luck,
Amb
-------------------------------
Dear Quailman,

You are "Roux". Townie. You win when all threats to the town are deceased.

Good luck,
Amb
-------------------------------
Dear IO_SAMBO_OI
You are Edward Scissorhands. You are on the town side, and your goal is see the evil players dead.

Good luck,
Amb
-------------------------------
Dear Dragon Phoenix,

You are Victor Van Dort, a humble townie. There exists threats however to your remaining alive. Your goal is to eliminate those threats as best you can.

Good luck,
Amb
-------------------------------
Dear Sniklac16,
You are Jack Kerouac. Your life is being threated by evil players. Your goal is aid the rest of the town in lynching them.

Good luck,
Amb
-------------------------------
Dear MNOWAX

You will have to leave the chocolate factory for a little while. The town in which you live is undersiege from the mafia, and your vote will maybe help keep them at bay. You are "Willy Wonka", townie, and you win with the town when the bad guys are all dead.

Good luck,
Amb
-------------------------------
Dear SAbLLimiNal

Your role name is Axel Blackmar. You are on the town side, and will win with the town (That is when all the bad guys are dead)

Good luck,
Amb
-------------------------------
Dear Sentran

Being the kind that cares for others, you are appalled at the existence of murdering mafia in your town. So you, Gilbert Grape, decide to rededicate your life as a doctor.

Each night, you may select a person whom you can protect if they are attacked.

You win with the town.

Good luck,
Amb
-------------------------------
Dear Zag

The town needs an investigator. That investigator is you. You are Ichabod Crane, investigator. Each night you may choose a player to investigate.

Along the way, you may also find a player in need of redemption. You will recieve a PM when, and if that happens.

You win with the town.

Good luck,
Amb

[Amb]

Undercover Monk:

If Zag had investigated UM, UM would have been offered the chance to upgrade to a retired-cop who would unretire on Zag's death.

If the mafia had targetted UM, UM would be given the option of joining the mafia, but if he refused, he would have died (without doc protection)

If both happened on the same night, he'd have gotten the choice of which he wanted. If he picked copness, he'd have died (without doc protection)

Once one of the two options was taken, the other option would no longer occur.

Theme:
Once the theme was successfully stated, the mafia recieved fake claims - set aside. They never used them. One of the fake claims was quite risky.

Chaz: Did call the scum, but not before targetting, outing and eliminating the cop. Allowed the scum to lie low. Wish like anything he had the role of Jack Sparrow now

[ralphmerridew]

Chaz: [quote=Silverfire]Right now I'm leaning toward Sentran as a nightkill choice, for three reasons. He has made a few accurate observations, and on the whole is helping the town with his posts. He has been suspicious of enough townies that if the town does decide to look at the people he suspected, it won't be hard to let suspicion fall on Chaz or Mackay. Lastly, while he is contributing, he's not so vocal that he's likely to get himself lynched.[/quote]

Also, we were going to change our nightkill target from Mackay to DP, just to stoke town suspicion, but night ended before I could get the message in.

[Chaz]

Hmmm... so I was mostly right? (I hadn't even considered how it might draw attention to Mackay by selecting Sentran.) In any event, it was a great choice of night kill. Kudos.

I still maintain that Zag outed himself. He made it obvious that he thought my theory might be correct (that all townie roles were authors.) I'm certain that rm or Silver would have taken about three seconds to realize that the reason Zag (who's role was obviously "Ichabod Crane" from Sleepy Hollow) was freaking out so much about me outing power roles; I would have figured it out had I been mafia (clearly, since I did figure it out without even knowing for sure who the mafia were.) Plus the post where rm says that some roles fit with a cop theme. post 286 Zag should have dismissed my theory as "impossible" since he knew I couldn't be right, since he was a vanilla townie; that's what I would have done anyway. Instead he went the "jump up and down like an idiot who wants everyone to know why Chaz's theory is wrong" route and outed himself.

Zag killed Zag, so stop blaming Chaz. I just figured the suspicion would instantly fall on me when he got killed that night, so I outed him in the light of day. It was hardly my mess up. Mackay deduced who and what Zag was. I deduced who and what Zag was (and that he had investigated Mackay.) I'm certain it wouldn't have been very hard for mafia to figure it out if both Mackay and I did while we were townies.

So, Zag, who did you investigate that last night (if not me)? I say that you're lying based on what I read in post 540.
_________________
The enemy's base is down.

[Chaz]

Also, what did Snik feel was so important to say that it had to be said at night?
_________________
The enemy's base is down.

[Chaz]

[Zag]

If you think I would try to give any info after I was dead than you don't know me very well at all. I felt bad that my little joke made it seem I might be trying to.

For that, and the rest of it, bite me.

[Chaz]

[Zag]

[Chaz]

[MNOWAX]

[raekuul]

Chaz, the game is over, you can edit your posts now.

[ralphmerridew]

Well, Chaz, I don't know about my teammates, but I hadn't spotted Zag as the cop. If you'd kept your mouth shut, he probably would have lived.

[Sentran]

Well played Mafia. Boo to Chaz.
I've learned a lot from this game, and I kept up with the game throughout.
Looking forward to my next chance!
_________________
Sentran
"Speaking of double negatives, I haven't read greylab yet today." - Lifeinmomland

[Sniklac16]

I told everyone i was town but noooooo lol...Its ok though a new mafia game is starting soon and a new chance for tow to win
_________________
What lies behind us and what lies before us are tiny matters compared to what lies within us.

[Chaz]

[Undercover Monk]

man I really thought MNOWAX was mafia. Chaz you really screwed the pooch on this one but on the other hand when we lynched you the game immidately turned to boredom. all hail Chaz the most entertaining dufus to walk the hallowed halls of the grey labyrinth.
_________________
The Classic Blunders:
1. never get involved in a land war in Asia
2.Never go in against a Sicilian when DEATH is on the line
3. Never release Peyton Manning

[Zag]

I have to agree that I had MNO on the top of my list also, when I went out. Second on my list was Snik, taking over for sAb. It was more sAb's behavior than Snik's, though, that led me to that conclusion. DP had pointed out something suspicious he had done which made sense to me, though I'm afraid I don't recall what it was, now. In my last night I investigated DP before I was killed. He seemed as good a choice as any, and I wanted to verify that his comment wasn't meant as misleading.

Silverfire was the biggest surprise. I had him (her?) pegged as town.

[Chaz]

I straight up called everything. You guys were just foolish to ignore me.

I even sacrificed myself so town would understand that my intentions were pure. You goons blew it. Period.
_________________
The enemy's base is down.

[Zag]

Yep, you called everything. Everything that turned out to be correct, as well as everything that turned out to be incorrect. The problem for us, of course, is separating the wheat from the chaff. And we see that's a problem for you, too, I see. Except, of course, with your 20/20 hindsight.

[Sniklac16]

My game could still use a couple players
_________________
What lies behind us and what lies before us are tiny matters compared to what lies within us.

[Silverfire]

[Chaz]

Sorry Silver (and rm). I do not buy that you guys are idiots.

@Dopey: I didn't call "everything." I speculated about everything and finally concluded who mafia were. I then realized that my conclusions were based on my innocence, and proceeded to prove that which I could actually prove--that I was a townie.

It is not my fault that the rest of town chose to ignore the evidence when it was piled in neat stacks in front of them. As soon as rae asked "what if I'm not?" I had them. Granted, I thought Quail and then Mackay was with them, but I most definately caled Silverfire, and rm was my second best bet on who was scum.

I even said they'd kill Mackay that night (yes, that was an obvious kill), but I also said they'd off DP the next night--which was hardly obvious.

Mackay was right about one thing, however, I was so obsessed with "being right" that I lost sight of what was best for the game. I literally sacrificed myself for the greater good, but for all the good that did.
_________________
The enemy's base is down.