Secret Theme Mafia: Game Over! Mafia Wins!

[ralphmerridew]

3iff: Fred is as likely as any other player to start off mafia. No more, no less.

Vote: Amb Let the newb have a chance to play before starting the heavy bandwagoning.

[Zag]

Official vote count for the new page.

[Undercover Monk]

that votecount is wrong btw LOL Unvote I dont want to bandwagon the newb so I will join Jedo in voting. Vote:Lifeinmomland
_________________
The Classic Blunders:
1. never get involved in a land war in Asia
2.Never go in against a Sicilian when DEATH is on the line
3. Never release Peyton Manning

[Zag]

Is there an actual error that I've made? (That is, is there anything other than my interpretation of what a vote for the mod means, which was not an error?)

[3iff]

Hey, people are being really nice to me (at last). Probably feel guilty for killing me (well, my previous incarnation) off last night.

This niceness won't last...

[Undercover Monk]

no i was just messing with you Zag lol you are doin fine
_________________
The Classic Blunders:
1. never get involved in a land war in Asia
2.Never go in against a Sicilian when DEATH is on the line
3. Never release Peyton Manning

[Jedo the Jedi]

I think I saw what you are talking about Garou, Amb, but I've never really given that much stock. It's worth keeping an eye on. (Then again, I may be totally off-base and now look stupid.)

More Mom votes?
_________________
Paragon Tally: 18 mafia, 3 SKs (1 twice), 1 cultist, numerous chat scum...and counting.

[Deception]

Lifeinmomland interesting response, for the record I find that response scummy.

Also would like to note that MNO's two posts consist of RVS on someone as a way of not answering the RQS and a joke post.

There are plenty of game related things to comment on but MNO is trying to slide into the background it would seem.

Pert has answered my vote so I'll Vote: MNO

For the record, Lifeinmomland is my biggest scumread right now (although not that great, tis early on) but MNO needs to give us more content.

cjort also had a poor excuse for not answering the questions.

isuateikisa is MIA?
bgg1996 could you respond to when I said that I was referring to "real world?"

[bgg1996]

Thinking about it, yes, I would lie a whole lot more;
"Who am I? I am the president of the Universe, don't you recognize me?"
"You're the guy who owes me $100,000,000,000,000! And you are, too!"
"Don't you remember? It's me, your boyfriend."
"These aren't the droids you're looking for."
_________________
The one member below 18

[Undercover Monk]

any reasoning to go along with that deception? It's one thing to bandwagon for bandwagon's sake but quite another to say someone said or did something scummy.

What was it that momland said? I may have to lead a newb lynch.
_________________
The Classic Blunders:
1. never get involved in a land war in Asia
2.Never go in against a Sicilian when DEATH is on the line
3. Never release Peyton Manning

[Undercover Monk]

in fact the only even reasonable chance for a scum tell in the post is the opening paragraph....

[Deception]

Well.. I was planning to wait until others had responded before I said why, but since I made that post I've been considering it and I would still be fine in explaining.

Lifeinmomland analyzed the questions from a different perspective than anyone else did. She broke them down to the bare essence of "how could this trip mafia up?". Also she says that I'm fishing for info in a way that implies that I am going to use the information with malicious intent, yet goes on to answer them anyway. Anyone else seeing contradictory thought process which not only points finger of suspicion at me(a townie) and blends in with the crowd by answering the questions like almost everyone else?

The answer to her first two questions are very inaccurate and tell me nothing.

Answer to question three starts out questioning the question, which is fine but I think that combined with the answer that attempts to destroy the question itself is suspicious.

Answer to question 4 is null.

Answer to final question is null for now.

[MNOWAX]

[Amb]

Deception is currently responsible for more than 10% of the posts in this thread. The phrase give a man enough rope, and he will hang himself doesnt really work here - when Deception makes the rope himself - but it does work in this context:

Deception will a) Out himself as a threat to the mafia if his content starts impinging on their freedom, or b) Out himself as mafia thoroughly - the more a scum posts, the more that cracks can appear.

So while I am in favour of FOSing him, I'd much prefer to lynch someone who lies low while appearing to still be following the game.

[Amb]

What I am saying here is: Deception plays in a way that guarantees his own death long term. So why waste time right now lynching him on day 1. Go for a player who contributes very little long term. It's a bit early to know who that will be, but candidates will start appearing not too far from now.

[Sentran]

While I disagree with MNO's reasoning, I agree with the target.
Unvote, Vote: Deception
_________________
Sentran
"Speaking of double negatives, I haven't read greylab yet today." - Lifeinmomland

[Deception]

[Amb]

Unvote; Vote Sentran

[bgg1996]

Deception, what was the last game of mafia you played?
_________________
The one member below 18

[Deception]

[bgg1996]

What not when was your last ended mafia game.
_________________
The one member below 18

[Deception]

[bgg1996]

I can't help but notice that in said game, although you answered other's questions, you didn't ask anybody else questions.
Did you just start that now?
_________________
The one member below 18

[Deception]

[bgg1996]

That's all for now.
_________________
The one member below 18

[Jedo the Jedi]

I'm happy with my Mom vote for now. I'll try to read back over (probably Monday) and see if I can pull out some awesome scum tell.

(Does the arrogance ever end, you ask. The answer is no.)
_________________
Paragon Tally: 18 mafia, 3 SKs (1 twice), 1 cultist, numerous chat scum...and counting.

[Undercover Monk]

[Deception]

[Lifeinmomland]

In post 92 Decption says I have a different perspective than most. He skews my perseption to his own uses, as I perdict he will continue to do with most of the answers people give. My perspective is not "How could this trip mafia up?" but is in fact "How will the mafia twist my words to thier advantage?"

It might help for you to know I proceed into games with a guilty until proven innocent mentality.

I agree with Monk, how is my answer any more inaccurate than most others? You are looking for ways to twist my answers already. I could go back on this list I guess, had I time, to see if I had played mafia in any other game, but none but the first stand out in my memory at all. Unfortunaly I don't have time to that. Since you seem to expect the rest of use to keep a detailed list of the when, where, and what of all our mafia games, shall we expect you to post a complete listing of yours now?

I question #3. Yes I do. Perhaps I am bit paranoid, but I expect later on someone will come along and say... "See so and so is scum! In is answers to Decptions questions he even says he would lie!" Or inversly "He said in would not lie and more than normal and we just caught him in this lie! He must be scum!" It is a question that is designed to give fodder to you mafia people. The fact that you asked it in the first place is skevvy.

The answer to my last questions are null apperently.

Honestly, I feel you are the scummest out here so far. I will state, and the players that know me can attest to this, I hate random day one silly voting. I answered your questions because I felt, and still feel that dispite the inane quality of question 3 it is better than random silly voting. It gets us moving to a conclusion sooner than silliness, and rahter than dragging on for days and becoming boring, this has proved interesting much sooner.

I fell comfortable putting my vote out now. VOTE DECEPTION
_________________
Who is John Gult?

[Deception]

[Amb]

Unvote; Vote LifeinMomLand

[Undercover Monk]

Ambs votes with no explanation are worrying me.
_________________
The Classic Blunders:
1. never get involved in a land war in Asia
2.Never go in against a Sicilian when DEATH is on the line
3. Never release Peyton Manning

[Undercover Monk]

[Deception]

[Lifeinmomland]

Just so we are clear, what same thing? The specific reason I am scummy is? That I think you are trying to draw out info for later twisting while pretending to be a helpful townie? So an opinion not your own is what you find scummy??

And I agree AMB random voting is odd for him. Perhaps he has been possessed by MNO?

So, it is a small fact but I begin to wonder how much reading of posts you do if you have missed this rather simple fact.
post 9

[bgg1996]

Deception, hat are the points of questions 1 and 3?
I would understand how many games of mafia have you played, but why specify scum games?
And anybody who doesn't say that they would tell somebody that they were the president or something similiar in question 3 is a liar.
_________________
The one member below 18

[Deception]

[bgg1996]

[bgg1996]

[Deception]