Mafia 46-Konfusion

[Neo]

vote no rule change Part of the whole game seems to be that nobody knows anybody, and therefore mafia should be killed at night if they recieve the majority. Also, the mod posting night choices really takes a lot of lying out of the game, which is a predominant theme in mafia. It wouldn't be too hard to figure out who's mafia after a while.

[El Blobbo revived]

Actually, you were voting for the first one. The events of night one make the game flexible enough to call them a fluke and change the rules. If enough people want it, I'll post the roles of the dead.

[mith]

EB: are you reading our posts? this game is pointless if the mafia can not kill each other. if you are unwilling to change this, find a replacement for me.

[El Blobbo revived]

I was saying I could do that tonight and ever after, pretending that it was a fluke night one. And I was talking to Neo.

[cubestudent]

vote: mafia can be killed at night + no revelation of targetting

[Tyenar]

I second cubestudent.

but no role revealing, that would take some of the fun out of it

------------------
Died 3 times in 2 nights in 1 game - Pokemafia

[wordcross]

okay, i've been persuaded to change my vote to what cube just said...

------------------
I do what my Rice Krispies tell me to...
And of course whatever EEEM says ...

[Soothsayer]

mafia have to be able to be killed at night. With 5 mafia alive there is little chance the town can win without accidental night time deaths

[mith]

*~waits for a response that is understandable before he sends a choice~*

[Tyenar]

Mafia must die at night because else the docters must stop at least one night kill and two more for every day the town lynches an innocent for the town to win. It is all but imposible for the town.

I'm up for restarting if that is what it takes, or else revising the rules and going on from here.

------------------
Died 3 times in 2 nights in 1 game - Pokemafia

[Ghost Post]

Well, if you add in the rule that when the mafia targets another mafia, there is a no-kill night, then the town at least has a chance. But I'd still say that allowing mafias to be killed at night is the fair way to go.

[Tyenar]

El Blobbo, could you make a decision soon about what to do? I would like to keep playing this, the premise is so fun.

------------------
Died 3 times in 2 nights in 1 game - Pokemafia

[Soothsayer]

wonders whether this mafia is going to finish

[radwulf]

shakes head in disbelief

[Dragon Phoenix]

attempt to fix...

[mole]

It's fixed. Elayne and I tried (and failed) to move a corrupt thread into GLOC. The thread didn't survive the journey , but VG should be back now. It is for me, at least..

[mith]

*~bump~* I believe this is why we were discouraging children from Moderating?

Does anyone want to take over and start this thing over? I will if no one else wants to, though I was having a blast playing

[ralphmerridew]

I'm also willing to take over modship, and I already emailed El Blobbo asking for the roles. Considering that I'm dead, I think that would be less disrupting on the game.

[mith]

I'd rather just start over, given the confusion over the rules.

Of course, I guess that's part of the game, eh?

[ralphmerridew]

In that case, unless EBr resumes within 24 hours, or anybody objects, I will restart the game. groza528 gets first crack at the empty spot, if he wants it.

[groza528]

I accept. I responded to your email, ralphm.

[El Blobbo revived]

Wait! Wait! I can mod! Two people never sent choices! If I don't get them by 2:00 GLT, the night will end, and the two players will be deemed inactive at 4:00 GLT, unless they reconfirm by email. Ironically, one of them has posted recently.

[mith]

Ironically, I was waiting for you to answer our questions. There's no point in playing if you aren't going to make it clear what's going on. EB, you've been gone a week. Is this going to be normal? If so, I suggest you let someone else mod.

[El Blobbo revived]

Night is now over. Soothsayer is dead. Vote!

[cubestudent]

I'm guessing I was one of those two whose night-choice you didn't get.

it's because, like mith, I was waiting for you to clarify the rules before I sent one in. you never clarified the rules, hence, I didn't send one in. you didn't even acknowledge our questions. in fact, you refrained from posting for almost 6 days. mods shouldn't do that.

/out

[El Blobbo revived]

Okay, mafia can be killed at night, but I don't know about the revealing of roles yet. A replacement topic for mith and cubestudent has been created

[mith]

EB, you are quickly losing my respect as a moderator. You failed to answer any questions until the post in which you kicked myself and cubestudent out. I don't really expect you will be able to continue this game.

[El Blobbo revived]

Okay, here's what happened: I didn't get yours or cubestudent's choices, so I emailed both of you about it, saying that you would be kicked out at 4:00, and also that night would be over at 2:00. I'm not going to be gone this much anymore, and, in my defence, I didn't see that post. I decided to be fair given the circumstances, I'll let you in, and since cubestudent apparently left the game, it looks like I need a replacement player.

[groza528]

I'll take cube's spot.
I'd like to make sure the rules are clear though...
Mafia CAN be killed at night, the roles of the dead will NOT be revealed, and night choices MAY be revealed BY THE PLAYERS if they choose to reveal them?

[groza528]

Unless cube decides he wants to stay that is.

[El Blobbo revived]

Yes, those are the rules we're using now.

[cubestudent]

cube is still out. not out of petulance or anything, I'm just trying to reduce the amount of free-time I spend online, because I'm burning up so much of it trying to learn go.

[Tyenar]

Well since it is day, and no on wants to be the first to vote, I'll go.

Vote: quercitron

no reason, too tired to think well, just voting because I can

------------------
Died 3 times in 2 nights in 1 game - Pokemafia

[quercitron]

OMG you suck! Vote: Tyenar

Picked Sooth, did we?

[wordcross]

apparently we did. Vote: Quercitron for lack of a better idea. Come on everybody! Jump on the bandwagon!!!!

------------------
I do what my Rice Krispies tell me to...
And of course whatever EEEM says ...

[Neo]

vote Tyenar

[Tyenar]

We? I don't know about any we. Maybe you picked Soothsayer.

And what's with that reasonless vote Neo?

------------------
Died 3 times in 2 nights in 1 game - Pokemafia

[Neo]

Reasonless because I'm completely confused. Did I miss the sooth death scene?

[El Blobbo revived]

I'm not doing death scenes, but Soothsayer is dead.
Marker

[Werebear]

I think the biggest problem, besides the mod's lack of posting, is that this game was called "MAFIA"... that name implies certain rules that are not even hinted at here. It should have been called "A Stab In The Dark - A Mafia-Type Game".. *Grin*

Werebear