Hobbit Mafia! (no. 54) [FINITO!]

[Macros]

1 mith, 1 jade

[Bear Skin Rug]

1 Bourbon, 1 Scotch, 1 Beer.

-BSR

------------------
...So now you think you can walk all over me, huh?

[jadesmar]

Oh, great a vote from a non-confirmed cop. Thing look bad for me.
Nice move giving away your buddies like that. And, nice move quitting after voting for me. Now, only you or I can be lynched today. Luckily, you have now also given yourself away.
unvote: mith
vote: TCM
Die mafia scum.

Now, for the aid of Neo and mith:
1. Role claim time: I am the Lord of the Eagles. I have the ability to choose someone at night. That person will be safe from goblins and/or wargs. Half doc role. I also have no effect on trolls and can not investigate.
2. Yes I know that this is the role you are alluding to TCM but you are a liar. How could the Lord of Eagles possibly have investigative powers?
3. And now, I, like TCM, am going to quit and let mith and Neo decide. If they are still around.

[mith]

I have no idea who anyone is... I'm Gollum. I was supposed to kill Bilbo, though someone got to him first. I think I'm just a townie now, that's what the email implied. Haven't actually done anything since the first night, when I checked Hy. I'll vote later.

[Neo]

bump for now

TCM(F) What exactly did you investigate for? Goblins and/or wargs?

[Macros]

come on and lynch someone already

[mith]

I just realized that we have 1 bad guy and 3 good guys. Classical Mafia strategy says: no lynch. That's what I want, if I can convince Macros that his "Thou must lynch" is a silly idea.

[Macros]

meh meh, mith convinced me to allow a no-lynch if the town desires it

[Neo]

Mith, it's up to you or me, either TCM(F) or Jade is lying and is a troll.

I investigated jade and got an innocent result, which must be disregarded because I see trolls as innocent.

Either way there is 1 troll left, unless all three of you are evil and kill me

[Neo]

I'm going to believe TCM for now.....

vote Jade

Mith, it's up to you....

[Macros]

er, i think its
2 jade
1 TCM

[mith]

Well, on one hand, jade is right, you'd think that role would be a protecting role.

On the other hand, it seems too convenient for her. She just happens to have the role TCM(F) claimed, she just happens to not be able to protect from Trolls, and I don't think TCM(F) would claim that particular role as a cop unless it actually was (i.e. if he knew the books well enough to pick that role, he'd know that the Lord of the Eagles would seem perfect as a protector). I'd be trying to outguess Macros here if I was basing my vote solely on that, so:

I will Vote: jade simply because TCM claimed first.

[Macros]

Jadesmar the Troll is dragged to the tree and hung.

well now is a odd istuation to be in

The town Celbrate their victory, but as they do so mith stoops to the ground screaming "My precious, I've found it!" and he flees to the mountains.
The Town Ties with Gollum, see role info to understand.

[mith]

oh, go us good game all.

I should've won (well, gotten credit for winning, I mean) this a long time ago. I had a great plan to get Hy lynched, but I was gone and then he revealed himself so I couldn't do it. Then I tried to kill Hy, but Macros decided that since whatever group PP was in got their choice in first, they found the ring. Bah. Then we nailed PP, yay.

[Macros]

oh sure mith blame me, you choice was scraping into the deadline anyway

[Macros]

ok, for the full game stuff, choices and all that jazz go here

sorry for the shit ending

[Neo]

Umm, w00t! I think this is the first time I survived!

[Macros]

ok, post game blabber,
ay ideas to improve on the roles (miths already thrown alot at me for Gollum)
mistakes i made
improvments in my "style"
anything in general i need to work on to make LotR run more smoothly

[PuzzleProdigy]

Mith, you could have had the ring, it didn't do me any good.

[jadesmar]

Almost made it. So close..

[Neo]

What kept me torn at the end and leaning toward TCM was that I checked out jade earlier, got an innocent, and knew all the goblins and wargs were gone. I'd gotten a hint with Smaug, but didn't find out about the third troll until about 10 minutes before I voted jade

[Macros]

just a question for mith or someone who knows, have a role such as jeeps and fezziks control voting been done before?

[jeep]

Yes, there have been roles that control votes before. I don't like the "cannot reveal yourself" to the others in the thread rules. I guess I generally don't like roles that really control what you can and cannot say in the thread.

-JEEP

[Macros]

well, i didnt know the control voting had been done before