Mafia 47 Magic:TG the Game

[ralphmerridew]

Vote: mole

[sketchwick]

Mole, I'd be happy to talk to you, what about?

sketchwick

[mole]

Does the deadline still apply? I think this might be the first unanimous lynching.

[Fezzik]

Well then; the towns people follow mole to the old lynching tree and watch as he puts the noose around his own neck, and pulls the lever. As confirmed by DPW, mole was a Phyrexian. 1 more Phyrexian dead as Night falls over the town. Night people send me your choices by:5-25-02 at 5:00pm.

[Sparhawk]

Geez, I log on this morning and find out that an entire day has run by. Anyway, I will belately Vote: Mole.

[ralphmerridew]

Actually mole, I got a unanimous lynching the first day in 46, but the game ground to a halt shortly after that, so I'm not sure if that counts.

[radwulf]

Antrax, I don't envy you, although I respect you both as a player and a person, but I think you're guilty this time (something about the way you post in this game, the no lynch plan, and how you voiced your opinion of Fezzik's time limits). I'm just suggesting that DPW investigate you or Querci, I'm highly suspicious of you two.

[Antrax]

Fine by me. I have nothing to hide. It's a waste of time, though.
Antrax

------------------
I'm cool, really

[quercitron]

*agrees with Antrax*

radwulf, you're always highly suspicious of me. just because the Corleones kicked your ass in Mafia 45 doesn't mean I'm always out to get you.

[jeep]

Wow, night already...

-JEEP

[Fezzik]

Day breaks, and the town comes together to find that mith is missing. They arrive at mith's house to find the helpless Elf dead with 4 black wounds. 1 Elf dead, time to vote. 8 needed to lynch. The vote deadline is: 5-28-02 at 5:00pm.

[Dread Pirate Westley]

*Shrug* Found an elf. Discuss amongst yourselves. By Day 3, the all-knowing Antrax (or someone else) should have some suspicions.

Anyone who wants to vote no kill, I give you with this math:
Chance of lynching a phyrexian if we lynch no one=0%
Chance of lynching a phyrexian if we lynch someone>0%

------------------
I do not have a crush on Elayne. I'm infatuated with her.

[sketchwick]

vote no lynch

We have a 4 in 15 chance of getting a phyrexian, but a 2 in 15 chance of lynching a doctor, then the doctor will have to come out and the other doc will have to protect them, who will have to protect DPW. Oh, but what if mafia claims to be a doc? Since our doc haves names they will have to claim a name, so the real named doc will denounce them. Now we will have two docs, which to lynch? Even if we lynch neither, who should our docs protect? Bah, it's a mess.

We don't lynch and the mafia will have a worse chance randomly hitting a doc. ALSO, they have no idea if you (DPW/Karn) are building the "exposed mason lodge" or if they are killing the elves you are investigating. The are dying for or help, can't you hear them, "please lynch some innocents, please help us find the docs, please don't win easily with this simple plan."

sketchwick

[radwulf]

If someone claims doc, we don't lynch them... if someone with that role dies in the future, then we lynch. I'm still suspicious of Antrax for the little mistakes he's made and Querci for trying to kill me. I would have insisted more on Antrax, but DPW would have investigated him already, I think... if not, he's got plenty of time to do it. Querci on the other hand is not as famous as Antrax, so there might be a while until DPW gets to him. And since he did attempt to murder me yesterday, I feel compelled to vote quercitron

PS: as for the mafia 45 business, there were very few active townies that made sense in that game (I can only recall Bremmer and DP in this category) and a ton of active, outspoken mafia... plus 3 killing factions in a town of 20 or so are too many. I for one was pretty good at figuring out a lot of the mafia in that game, but no one listened to me, because most of the active players were criminals themselves. Why am I telling you all this? I have absolutely no idea... oh yes, because querci brought mafia 45 up to insinuate that hard feelings from that game might be influencing me here. No, that's not the case, I assure you. When somebody tries to murder me, I must retaliate.

PPS: Querci, you're a much nicer person when you write poetry than when you play mafia, especially when you ARE mafia

[Antrax]

[ralphmerridew]

Well, I still wonder what the truth in Bladerunner is... but I do think that voting no kill while there's a cop and two doctors is to our advantage.

Vote: no kill

[sketchwick]

Just want to thank Antrax, if it's one thing he's good at (from what games I have read that he is in) it's starting a bandwagon. This game would have been horribly depressing if I had spent it trying to convince the town my plan was the best idea while they make me watch them screw it all away. Seriously, if the minotaur hadn't died this game would be a town win SO FAST.

sketchwick

[Fezzik]

Umm.. mith, have you seen the first post lately? You died last night. Just thought I'd let you know.

[mith]

Oops, I'm not paying attention lately. Bah. *~floats off~*

[U.V.G.F.]

Vote: No kill

[jeep]

Can we vote: no kill?

If not, I'll put in my alternate of U.V.G.F.

-JEEP

[Sparhawk]

Vote: No Kill

[U.V.G.F.]

Why would you vote for me, jeep?

[jeep]

UVGF, I have a mark next to your name that indicates that I think you said something that I thought was suspicious. I look back now and cannot see what it was. I need to make more detailed notes, I guess.

So confirm vote: no kill and I'll take back UVGF as my "if we cannot avoid lynching" vote. Have we been told if not lynching is an option in this game?

-JEEP

[Antrax]

Jeep, since we've done it last round, yes, I tend to believe it is.
Antrax

------------------
I'm cool, really

[jeep]

Hmm... yeah, I guess we could just not get a majority, but that means waiting 4 days. OK, I'll go take a nap to see if I can start thinking again.

-JEEP

[quercitron]

Vote: no kill

[quercitron]

[ralphmerridew]

As long as we have a cop and two doctors, I think we're better off dragging this part on.

Vote: No Kill

[sketchwick]

Jeep or Antrax: Is it legal for me to ask the Phyrexians if they wish to concede?

sketchwick

[Antrax]

Err, why wouldn't it be? "A player may concede at any time", or so the rulebook says.
Antrax

------------------
I'm cool, really

[Tyenar]

I've never liked "no kill" too boring, but I do see when it is to our advantage.

Vote: no kill

------------------
Died 3 times in 2 nights in 1 game - Pokemafia

[sketchwick]

Antrax: I think there is a rule about asking or suggesting your opponent concede...something to do with colusion.

Jeep?

sketchwick

[Ferris]

Vote: No kill

[jeep]

Sketch: As long as you don't introduce any outside incentive, it is legal to ask your opponent if they wish to concede. If this were say a PTQ and you were to say "you take the travel voucher, I'll take the invite" that is legal. If you were to say "you take this $500 check and I'll take the travel voucher and I'll take the invite" That is not legal.

Edit to add: Oh, and if the opponent says no, you can't keep asking.

-JEEP
DCI judge

[This message has been edited by jeep (edited 05-27-2002 02:40 AM).]

[sketchwick]

Phrexians: Would you like to concede?

sketchwick

[Phrexians]

sketchwick: No

Phrexians

[This message has been edited by Phrexians (edited 05-27-2002 12:57 PM).]

[Fezzik]

For the past two days I've been unable to view the last page of this thread.(because of webtv) I might not be able to see it tomorrow; being the deadline this could be a problem. I will be able to see it(while at school) tomorrow at 8:30 a.m. GL time. I am sorry for any problems this may cause.

[sweetwater]

Vote: No kill

[Soothsayer]

vote: No kill