New Mafia System - vote now!

[Lucresia]

Vote: Free Market

[Antrax]

Vote Tally:
Free Market: 7 (Antrax, Kazooish, Xer0x, Dragon Phoenix, Cyberdork, Quercitron, Lucresia)
15 to lynch, Deadline in 48 hours.
~marker~
Antrax

------------------
"If it comes down to a choice between being unloved and being vulnerable and sensitive and emotional, then you can just keep your love." -Victor Mancini, "Choke"

[Neo]

How about a list of blacklisted mods? Mods who have routinely run games and abandoned them, or failed to enforce rules, allowed days/nights to drag, etc.

[Vegtable2001]

Vote Macros FOS on TANSTAAFL

------------------
Thats my opinion.... I probably don't care about yours

[mith]

Vote: my idea (a merger of the mafiascum and old list ideas), which is like the Libertarian Party or something (getting ignored). But I don't really care either way.

[Samadhi]

Why the quick deadline? It's like saying "The sun is going to explode in millions of years! We need to decide what to do about it by next Tuesday!"

[mith]

Yeah, geez, we need to be cautious!

[TANSTAAFL]

Hey, I didn't know I was in this game! How'd I become so suspicious?

vote: whatever

yes I'd like to mod a game, but if there is this much controversy about it, I don't have to. Whatever is decided I'll go along with. I'm a player, not a mod (or at least maybe just a one time mod )

[Corsato]

Vote: freeforall, it's the only way to cut down on the waiting list.

[Lilifreid]

I like the idea of a blacklist for repeated failures.

[Macros]

vote free for all with the blacklisting idea

[Agamemnon]

Vote: The opposite of Antrax

[Amb]

Vote no lynch

[Amb]

vote free for all with the blacklisting idea



[This message has been edited by amb (edited 11-23-2002 06:15 PM).]

[Antrax]

mith, what, exactly, is your idea?

Macros or whomever, who exactly will maintain the list? And who defines if a game was successful or not?
Antrax

------------------
"If it comes down to a choice between being unloved and being vulnerable and sensitive and emotional, then you can just keep your love." -Victor Mancini, "Choke"

[mith]

See Reply 42.

[PuzzleProdigy]

Macros/Neo(who, incidentally, has never run a GL game, so would someone please tell me how he did at modding on mafiascum?): Um, what purpose would the blacklist have in a free-market scenario? The purpose of the free-market would be that no one signs up for games run by a bad mod.

Vote: Free Market

Free Market mafia modding is like democracy: "The worst system except all of the others."

[This message has been edited by PuzzleProdigy (edited 11-24-2002 10:54 AM).]

[Neo]

The blacklist would be posted for the newer incoming players who may not know who the bad mods are.

[Antrax]

Neo, have you read my question? Who maintains the list and who decides which games are bad?
~adds "The mafiascum.net solution" to the fray~
Antrax

------------------
"If it comes down to a choice between being unloved and being vulnerable and sensitive and emotional, then you can just keep your love." -Victor Mancini, "Choke"

[Neo]

Antrax: No, I saw the post, but it said Macros, so I skipped it

Who maintains the list isn't really an issue (IMO) I was thinking just a thread floating around (or locked at the top if a GL Mafia Forum is opened) with a list.

As for deciding if a game was bad, I still think it's fairly easy to tell. Anybody outside the game can tell if days and nights consistantly drag on with little done about it. The players can tell since they were in direct contact. The exact requirements (ie what makes a mod bad, a game bad, how many games before a mod is blacklisted, etc) could be hammered out by the players and mods as a whole if the idea were to be accepted.

[Antrax]

What if I run a 20 player game, 5 players hated it and 15 loved it? What if outsides say the nights took forever, but all the players thought it's peachy because they were busy? If the thread is locked on top, who can edit the post, and if it's a regular thread, who can post to it?
Not so trivial.
Antrax

------------------
"If it comes down to a choice between being unloved and being vulnerable and sensitive and emotional, then you can just keep your love." -Victor Mancini, "Choke"

[Neo]

[Vegtable2001]

Vote Freemarket I want to try modding a game without waiting for days (got a them planned)

------------------
Thats my opinion.... I probably don't care about yours

[Lilifreid]

Waiting for days!!!

Laughs hysterically

That's the funniest thing I've heard all week....

Hyperventilates from laughing so hard

[Fezzik]

~gives Lili a paper bag to breath into~
vote:free market

------------------
I am EEEM's minstrel.
Oh, and... "Anybody want a peanut?"

[mith]

Moving to Mafia Games...

[Lucresia]

Originally posted by Me, reply 51:

---

I really would like to mod a mini game please.

---

Originally posted by Macros, first post:

---

Mini Games - definite list and order will depend on old list as well
Quercitron
CyberDork
Kazooisch
TANSTAAFL

---

I take that as a no then Macros?

[Werebear]

Someone please update the first post, or give me permission to update it? *Grin*

[Dragon Phoenix]

I thought I had already closed this one. Discussion over, we have started the free market. Everybody can start the sign-up for any type of game thy like at any time.