Small Mafia: Town wins

[Vegtable2001]

Querc, the last thing we want is for a cop to come out.

[Green Crayons]

Whatever. I'm more suspicious of Rubberduck than Werebear. But just so we dont sit around all month with a thumb up our butt, Unvote: Trevize, Vote: Werebear.

[Werebear]

Well, I can't claim cop. I can, however say I am a member of the town[/b], and what my goal is. It's [i]to eliminate the evil that, I'm sorry to say, has invaded our small town. Maybe this will make some of you see fit to unvote me. If not, please tell me, and I'll explain further.

[Werebear]

Pretend the tags are fixed, please. *G*

[quercitron]

Unvote: Werebear

*moves Werebear to innocent list.*

Vote: RubberDuck

[Green Crayons]

Unvote: Werebear, Vote: Rubberduck

Baa.

[quercitron]

Okay, we're not getting much of anywhere. Yes, RD seems suspicious to me, so I'd like to bandwagon him (actually, I'd like to lynch him, since I suspect he'll claim Townie even if he isn't and not lynching him will probably get us nowhere.)

But maybe there are some other ways to generate discussion.

I'm going to make a list of players from most suspicious to most likely innocent, in my mind. Maybe if everyone else does the same we can analyze them.

Mine goes like this:

RubberDuck
Degenerate
Trevize
Vegtable2001
Green Crayons
Werebear
quercitron

[Green Crayons]

Easy enough.

Rubberduck
Trevize
Dengenerate
Vegtable
Quercitron
Werebear
Green Crayons

Trevize is my runner up basically because he unvoted Pika so that he wouldn't "bloody his hands with innocent blood," and then Pika voted him. It's a two in one deal: 1) In Trevize shoes, he doesnt want to look lynch happy. 2) Pika (fellow scum?) tossed a vote to Trevize for a crap reason, banking on the fact that perhaps the town wouldn't think the town/cop would believe scum would be bold enough to blantantly draw attention to each other?

[Vegtable2001]

I'm tempted to agree with GC, simply because he/she has been pretty accurate so far with suspicion.

------------------
Thats my opinion.... I probably don't care about yours

[quercitron]

You put yourself in the middle Veg?

[RubberDuck]

If no one would belive me,what would be the purpose of claiming town?

I,D

[quercitron]

Well, you could claim Mafia instead, that would work. Not very many people go for that one though.

[RubberDuck]

Did you not notice the I,D Mr spy?

[Werebear]

I noticed it, but it isn't registering anything with me. Am I supposed to know something about it?

[RubberDuck]

I was calling quercitron Mr spy, not you werebear, That I,D was a hint for everyone though because Q's the Mafia spy.

[Degenerate]

Hmm.. is that so?

Unvote: Werebear

[Degenerate]

Interesting.

[Green Crayons]

...I dont follow. Unvote: Duck. You have to explain things out very carefully, pretty much spelling them out word for word because i'm quite slow.

[Trevize]

Green Crayons - I must say, I like you reasoning for putting me second on the list. It needs a little revision but I think you can go back and not read into my words too much. I am using my same thought process of my latest post on Designer Mafia, I welcome the cop to investigate me. I however don't think that Pika (or I ) would have been smart enouth to compose your #2 deal of confusing the cop by drawing attention to each other.
vote:Duck I want to know why you are saying quercitron Mr spy for the mafia. Anything to back that up?

[RubberDuck]

This is more of a gut feeling than anything else, but I dont have any proof other than this:

A common Mafia Spy trick is to Fos,Vote and then lynch half the amount of mafia players so that the townspeople think that they are innocent, then the spy informs the remaining mafia players on who they are and guide them on who's best to eliminate next.
I do have more than this but its too hard too explain at the moment, I'll have to think about it for a while before posting it so that it makes perfect sense to everyone

I hope this makes sense.

~takes deep relieving breath after all the typing

[quercitron]

Yeah, since there have been, you know 0 Mafia Spies who know the Mafia and are able to communicate with them at will. I really hope you're Mafia just trying to bluff your way out of a lynch, because as it stands your attack is just silly. And before you ask, I've already told you I only have a strong gut feeling on you. It hasn't gone away. Making up "common Mafia Spy Tactics" only makes me more suspicious.

I would also like to point out that a common straight Mafia tactic is to sacrifice a comrade to look innocent. However, I wouldn't have done that with pika if a family member had already died, and anyone who honestly thinks I sacrificed pika when I could just have easily tried to attack someone else needs to take a good look at the thread. Not that there's much there. Discussion, people!

[Trevize]

Well I don't think there would be a spy mafia in a Minin game.

[RubberDuck]

Now I see why Amb told me never to play a mafia game that your in.
Your too damn hard to figure out.

[TANSTAAFL]

Vote update:

RubberDuck -2- (Quercitron, Trevize)

[Werebear]

*sigh* I also don't understand how RubberDuck's defense is meaningful.
Vote: RubberDuck

One vote away from a lynch.

[Degenerate]

Couldn't it be possible that RD's the cop and he investigated quercitron, and he's trying to imply that q's guilty?

[Green Crayons]

Eh, i'm close to revoting Duck, i just a role claim first.

If Duck is the cop and found Q guilty, why not just come out and denounce him now, instead of doing this whole "maybe he's a spy!" deal?

[Degenerate]

Maybe he wants to live longer.

[Trevize]

With such a small game, if Rubberduck were the cop and knew something, he should have come out and said so.

[Werebear]

...if he's a cop and has found a mafia, he should have come out immediately, especially with two mafia and a SK dead in a mini game?? I've seen cops come out for a lot less. I'm actually surprised a cop hasn't come out yet... my bet is that all (or most) their investigations were killed.

RubberDuck - if you're a cop, now would be a pretty darned good time to say so.

[Degenerate]

Who cares, he probably isn't one anyway.

Vote: Rubberduck

[Vegtable2001]

Somehow i doubt RD is a cop. He has had ample opportunity to claim it. From what i can tell, he specifically denies this in post 139. I'm also not really convinced he is mafia. I just don't think it's very subtle for what might be the last remaining mafia, to run around accusing people of being spies. I may be overestimating him, but i don't think RD is maf either. That being said, I also think his accusation of querci is a bit out of the blue. Our only reason to suspect him, is RD's "gut feeling" however, that still gives us just as much reason to suspect him as anyone else. That being said, i really don't have anyone to vote for now

------------------
Thats my opinion.... I probably don't care about yours

[TANSTAAFL]

And so the town drags RubberDuck to the gallows and strings him up. When they go to cut the noose from his neck, they see what they missed before... the stethoscope that was already there. Dr. Rubberduck can help them no more...

It is night, send your choices... Deadline of 72 hours from now.

[Vegtable2001]

Posted too late.

------------------
Thats my opinion.... I probably don't care about yours

[Degenerate]

So much for that.

[Trevize]

"I,D" . . . Damn I'm an idiot!!! sorry Duck! So clear now <smacks his own head>

[RubberDuck]

I think TANSTAAFL gave me my role based on my name, you might say I was a bit of a quack.

Sorry cop no more help for you now.

[TANSTAAFL]

The sun rises once more, and the townspeople gather together to see who is missing this time. But as the look from one to another, counting on their fingers, they realize that they are all there. No one died. It is day. there are 6 alive, it is 4 to lynch.

[Vegtable2001]

Anyone have an explanation for this, other than a doc still alive? If that is true it might be worth it for the cop to come out, though this could be a mafia ploy to do just that. Anyone got any opinions on this?

[Trevize]

Killed so far: 4 townies + 2 doctors + 2 mafia + 1 serial killer = 9

it amuses me thatyou, Vegetable2001, is asking for the cop to come out because I am the Cop and last night I investigated you. My result from the MOD Vegetable2001 is EVIL. My gues is that he is the last mafia but has no power to kill at night.
The only one alive that I have also investigated is Dengenerate and he is GOOD.

vote: Vegetable2001