Chocolate Mafia: Game Over!

[Livingod]

*boogie*

Ok, I'll leave now...
_________________
ScumTube!
Endless Mafia. Replacements constantly needed.

[Mgm]

Okay people. The holiday season is over, there's no more excuses not to post. Deadline: January 8, my first chance to post.

[Talzor]

Hi, I'm back from my Holliday at my parents and I'm still think that Fuldu has the best case.

Unwrap, Wrap Amb.

[Fuldu]

I still want an answer from Amb regarding TCM's question (Did you protect me Night 3?) so that I can get an answer from TCM to my question (Why do you know that you were protected Night 3?). This is the only current line of inquiry that could result in my removing my wrap from Amb, so I'd think he'd be interested in moving it along.
_________________
"... through a combination of anagrams, wordplay, and trafficking in the occult."

[Amb]

No, I (Leo), did not protect TCM on night 3.

[Fuldu]

So neither of the claimed docs protected TCM Night 3. Would you care to clarify your comments, Cheshire?
_________________
"... through a combination of anagrams, wordplay, and trafficking in the occult."

[Pooky]

the pace of this game is absurd.

its like the Wheel of Time in slow motion.
_________________
3-1 against Mith in Fantasy Football.

[Mgm]

Since the pace is so slow, I'm sure you guys won't mind me doing to final vote count of the day tomorrow. Be sure to send your choice, though. Not sending one could easily be detrimental to your health for several reasons.

[Mgm]

Wrap count
Amb (3): Fuldu, Courk, Talzor
Fuldu (2): Amb, Pooky

You fail to reach a concensus and no one is lynched.
Night falls. Deadline: January 13[/b]

[Choctorjgm]

As day dawns in the chocolate box, the inhabitants are again greeted by a grisly sight. Fuldu is found shut in a barrel filled with vanilla ice cream and Talzor was replaced with a tasteless look-a-like with no sign of the real thing.

Fuldu - Oompa Loompa - backup doctor - smothered, night 7.
Talzor - Twix - oneshot lynch protected townie - replaced, night 7.

With 4 lives remaining, I take 3 to lynch...

[Amb]

When I awoke I had a message taped to my head that said "Ignore this message".

Anyone care to explain this? I assume it's a skilled ability that someone has in order to clear themselves?

[Amb]

For the record...

Vote Pooky

TCM is innocent. He wasnt playing for too long for the mod to have not replaced him due to missing choices. Ergo he has no choices to make.

A lynch protected scum makes sense with so many town roles with lynch or night immunity. I believe Pooky is the most likely of the living to be scum. I do not know if I can believe Courk or not. What are your opinions TCM?

[Mgm]

You chocolates better talk. You don't want to lose because you're modkilled. I know you're paying attention...

[Amb]

A modkill would be a complete disaster. Come'on guys...

[Courk]

Amb = team scum. Shocking.

So, amb and Pooky are scum. Two pro-town players left, two scum.

We can lynch one of them, and be left with 2 vs 1 going into night, then 1 vs 1 in the morning -- scum wins.

We can't lynch both of them.

If we don't lynch anyone, we can hope that they kill each other. At the worst, they don't kill each other and the town loses, which is what happens when one of them is lynched. I'd really hate to no lynch at this point, but it's the only chance the town has.

Vote: No lynch

[Amb]

You are kidding right? I hadn't even listed you as my prime suspect? Why the HECK would you post something that lets me know you are lying?

Unvote; Vote Courk

[pete d]

extremely late bah

[Amb]

Unvote; Vote No Lynch

I have considered the no lynch scenario. It really is our best chance. I do think that our scum are Courk and Pooky. And they will need to target each other for a town win. Neither will like the other to be left alive.

[Pooky]

Let us say that it is obvious that TCM is indeed innocent and that thus the 2 killers must be among us three, Amb Courk and Me.

Now consider then what the best move for the town at this point to be,

Is it to NL?

I say no!

I've actually played enough with 4 player 2 scum endgames enough to know what the correct move for the town is if the 2 scum are narrowed to be within 3 players.

It is to lynch the protown player within those three players.
What that does is eliminate all doubt from the mind of those 2 killers as to who the other killer is as well as to whether the other killer knows the other's identity.

Basically what it does is it makes the killers PUBLIC knowledge.

Right now of the three people, 2 among them being killers, only ONE person knows ABSOLUTELY for sure who those 2 killers are, that person is the innocent, he knows the other 2 r the killers, the 2 killers each only know that the other killer is one of the other 2.

It is in the TOWN'S BEST INTEREST TO MAKE SURE THAT BOTH KILLERS KNOW ABSOLUTELY WHO THE OTHER KILLER IS BECAUSE THAT FORCES THEM TO SHOOT EACH OTHER IN THE NIGHT. This is a key component of our gametheorying this endgame, that the identity of the 2 killers becomes public knowledge.

How is the only way to do that? It is to lynch the innocent among those three players, once the innocent is lynched, the lights come on, the curtains part, and it is clear as day who the 2 last scum must be.

Thus it is in our best interest to lynch the innocent amoung those three suspected.

That innocent happens to be me.

vote Pooky

I'm the other 1 time lynch protected townie, there were 2 lynch protected townies and 1 1time lynch protected townie dead, out of those I am the one that remains still alive.

Amb and Courk are the scum, and when I am hung, they will know it for certain and have no choice but to kill each other at night.

GO TOWN!
_________________
3-1 against Mith in Fantasy Football.

[Amb]

Unless you remain unlynchable, and you go into night alive, hoping that the remaining scum (Courk) will target me while you knock her off.

[Pooky]

I claimed 1 shot unlynchable

If the lynch fails on me this time, it will show that I was lying and thus scum.

ur screwed ambscum this time my case is ironclad.
_________________
3-1 against Mith in Fantasy Football.

[Amb]

I know 100% that courk is scum because she said she found me team scum.

I assume TCM is not scum because he was gone for so long. Unless his scum buddies were sending choices for him. Don't discount this.

I know 100% I am not scum.

I assume Pooky is scum, because an unlynchable scum would make sense in the game setup.

[Courk]

But, you're not innocent. You're the SK.

[Courk]

Pooky's not innocent*

[Courk]

Amb is also not innocent, but he's team scum, aka mafia.

I hate having to clarify simulposts.

[Courk]

Wait, how is unlynchable scum even fair? What is the town supposed to do?

[Amb]

Courk, you are as good as caught, so you may as well drop it. Your attempt to frame me must be taken in that light. I am not and have never been mafia.

[Pooky]

Obviously both of you are scum.

What an innocent person would have done upon reading my post would be to say, NO HES LYING IM THE REAL INNOCENT LYNCH ME.

Niether of you have done that, both of you continue to claim innocence.

Thus you 2 are the scum.

I've already outlined VERY clearly why the best move for the innocent one out of us three is to get himself lynched in order to expose the scum and force them to kill each other over the night. Since niether of you have done that, both of you must be scum .
_________________
3-1 against Mith in Fantasy Football.

[Amb]

Your plan confuses me completely. I'll wait on TCM and if he can explain to me why suicide works, then I will vote myself.

[Pooky]

cmon Amb, I know you aren't dense. And I don't exactly use words that r too big either.

If there are three people and 2 of them are scum, and EVERYONE KNOWS that 2 of the three are scum, then only the innocent of the three knows who the 2 scum are right?

Now if we kill the innocent one, there are two people and two of them are scum and thus THEY KNOW WHO THE TWO SCUM ARE!

It's in our best interest that the scum go into the night with the absolute knowledge of who each other are cuz then they will definitely shoot each other.
_________________
3-1 against Mith in Fantasy Football.

[Amb]

Gotcha.

Unvote; Vote Amb

[Pooky]

oh cmon amb, give it up, u and courk are as good as caught.
_________________
3-1 against Mith in Fantasy Football.

[Dan]

This is hilarious. Can't wait to see how it ends.

[Amb]

(It should end with Courk and Pooky blowing each other up. Pooky's gambit is that it will end in no lynch* and he comes out looking 'town'. He is right though, and I was thinking it was part of the bluff and discounting it earlier, we do need to lynch town. Hence my vote)

* On account of indecision

[Courk]

Unwrap
Wrap: No lynch

Pooky's not actually wrapping himself (nor is amb) which makes me more sure of their guilt, and I don't like dying to prove it.

[Pooky]

lol, if you were innocent courk u'd be wrapping urself.

the point about me voting instead of wrapping is just plain silly

wrap:Pooky
_________________
3-1 against Mith in Fantasy Football.

[Courk]

Unwrap

Wrap: Pooky

[Amb]

3 to lynch? Courk and Pooky are both wrapping Pooky?

Unwrap; Wrap Pooky

Lets get this to night, and see how badly I just screwed this up.

[Mgm]

That appears to be a lynch, please stop posting game related content while I check the votes and write a lynch scene.

[Amb]

* bump *